The Wrong Catch (The Wrong Player #3)

The Wrong Catch (The Wrong Player #3)

Author: C.R. Jane Listening Length: 15h 4m

I was his stalker. He was my religion. And somewhere between the lies and the worship, we fell in love. Everyone warned me that love could ruin you. They just never said it would feel this good while it burned. Matty Adler is the University of Tennessee’s golden boy—star tight end, campus legend, the kind of man girl...

Episodes

Listen Now

Now playing: CHAPTER 20

0:00 / 19:27

This episode is locked. VIP membership is required.

Current Episode

CHAPTER 20

OPHELIA

The diner Matty steered me into smelled like frying oil, pancake syrup, and coffee so strong it could probably polish a floor. Neon signs buzzed above a row of cracked vinyl booths, and the floor tiles were the kind of yellow-white that promised decades of stories under their scuffs.

If I’d been alone, I would’ve turned around and walked out. Noise pressed against me from every angle…forks scraping plates, ice rattling in glasses, laughter pinging off chrome-edged counters. I could feel my lungs tightening, my brain already negotiating exit strategies.

But then Matty’s hand tightened around mine, and all the anxiety flapping around inside me…it settled. “C’mon, pretty baby,” he murmured, tugging me toward the corner booth.