Chapter 36 Mateo
CHAPTER THIRTY-SIX
Mateo
Avery was pushing us to the edge on purpose. The thing was, it was working. But she was now trapped between us, and there was no escape. Not until I said so. I intended to keep her here until she was a begging mess.
I slid my fingers against her pussy, feeling how fucking wet she was. Drenched. Her folds were slick as I worked two fingers inside her, keeping an eye on her ass as Levi warmed up each cheek with his palm.
I loved seeing him like this. Slightly unhinged and needing to put her in her place.
She looked really good bent over like this for us.
She cried out as I slid my fingers in and out, pumping them like a cock.
I could feel her clenching around me, but it wasn't going to do anything but drive herself wild.
There was no escaping us. That was one of the best parts.
I'd watched her sit there and draw us while I put Levi on his knees, while she teased us with her legs spread and that fucking wet pair of red lace panties.
But now here she was.
Exactly where we wanted her.
Levi's palm struck her ass hard. The sound of his skin against hers rang through the gallery, her breath hitching as she was forced to drape over his thighs. Her wrists tied behind her back, the rope digging into her skin. She continued to rock her body, trying to wriggle free.
Eventually, she would give up. Eventually, she would completely give in.
This time, he spanked her other cheek. She cried out, but he didn't give her a moment to rest. His palm smacked each side of her ass, going until her cries grew sharp enough we both took note.
He eased up, rubbing each side, massaging the pain away until it was just a dull ache. Her skin was shades of pink and red, and if he kept going, we both knew there would have been a couple of marks.
We both knew that she would love that.
“Every time you spank her, I swear she gets wetter,” I whispered, thrusting my fingers harder.
Her ass wiggled as she mumbled our names repeatedly. Her wrists tugged against the ropes. Levi pinched one of the red marks he’d left on her ass and her voice filled the room, her head tossing to the side.
“Fuck!” she yelled.
“Too much?” he asked.
“No. No. Maybe. No. I want more. I’m so close.”
I sped up the pumping of my fingers and added a third. She humped her hips, her voice muffled as she moaned into the blankets. Levi turned his head to watch, his eyes glazed over with lust.
My cock was angry at me at this point. I was so fucking hard, it almost hurt.
But I didn’t want Avery to come yet.
“So close,” she whimpered. “So close.”
Levi was softening up to her. I could tell by the way he looked at her.
I pulled my fingers free and she cursed, turning her head to glare over her shoulder. It’d been awhile since I’d earned a glare from her, and in this context, I loved it. Her looking like she wanted to stab me turned me on.
“Mateo,” she growled.
“Yes, my love?”
“Fuck you.”
“Not yet, darling.”
“And fuck you too, Levi.”
He chuckled and replied by spanking her again.
“When you start behaving, you’ll get rewarded,” I said. “Or I can put you in a hog tie and Levi and I can fuck each other while you watch. And you can lay there and get nothing.”
Her head tossed, but instead of insulting me again, her body relaxed. She moaned as she draped herself over Levi.
“Are you going to be good for us, Avery?” I whispered.
She was quiet for a moment, but then she wriggled her butt. “Yes. I’ll be good. I promise.”
I wasn't quite sure I believed her. I smiled anyway, though. Mostly because she was so fucking cute. Sexy, too, but cute.
For a moment, it hit me that I was really doing this with one of my best friends. That we’d crossed that line and the world hadn’t ended. That we’d taken a leap, and now here she was, bent over for me and Levi.
I swallowed hard, trying not to think about what came after. Not after this scene or after tonight, but after Levi.
That pain swallowed me whole. I did my best to push it away and recenter myself, drawing in a breath to focus. It was something I’d deal with later, I reminded myself.
Besides, he was here with us now.
And that’s what mattered.
I adjusted my body so that I was next to Levi and able to spread Avery’s thighs apart. I leaned down, planting gentle kisses against the hot marks blooming on her ass cheeks.
Levi sucked in a breath. “I don't know if I can keep holding out. I need to come.”
“You will soon.”
His eyes fluttered, his cheeks flushed as he watched me push my tongue inside her. Avery whimpered, her hips rolling, as I pushed my tongue deeper, getting a taste of her. It wasn’t enough though. I wanted her to sit on my face and suffocate me.
I gave her ass a slap. “It’s time to take a ride.”
“A ride?”
“Yeah. On my mustache.”
Levi chuckled as he let her up. I laid back on the bed, the three of us doing our best to stay on the mattress. It was almost impossible. We really needed a king-sized bed and days to spend in it.
I wanted Avery to be as wet as possible before the two of us fucked her. And I wanted to make her come with my mouth before that happened.
She stood up, looking down at me, unsure. “I don’t know . . .”
“Sit on his face,” Levi said as he knelt between my knees.
“I don’t want to hurt him—”
“Avery,” I snorted. “Sit on my mustache, baby. Now.”
Levi didn't give her another moment to hesitate. Instead, he guided her over my body, and gave the backs of her knees, a tug, knocking her off balance. She squealed, but I caught her, lowering her down with ease. She straddled my head, her pussy right on my mouth.
But she still wasn't sitting all the way down yet.
I pulled her full weight down, burying my mouth against her cunt. My tongue lapped against her clit, and she immediately moaned, relaxing reluctantly. I could tell she was trying to hold some of her weight, but with her hands still tied behind her back it was almost impossible.
“Good girl,” Levi praised. “Ride his face, baby. You look so fucking hot right now.”
His voice was lost to the sounds she made as I fucked her with my tongue. She started to rock against me.
Levi’s calloused hand closed around my cock.
I was in heaven. Truly. Pleasure shot through me as he stroked me, and then the heat of his mouth wrapped around the head like silk.
My head was spinning as the taste of her filled my mouth. I lapped at her, wishing I didn’t need to breathe. Even so, I only took in a breath here and there, dedicated to making her orgasm.
It didn’t take too long before her movements became jerky and her hoarse cry hit my ears. She tensed, going still as her orgasm wrapped around her, demanding more. More and more. More pleasure and more desire and need and everything pleasurable.
Levi kept sucking my cock, his grunts adding vibrations along my shaft. I thrust my hips up and he took me deeper.
I’d made him wait long enough. I lifted Avery up and pushed him back on the bed so that he was laying flat. I tugged the ropes around her wrists, freeing her so that she could plant her hands on his shoulders.
“Take his cock,” I demanded.
“Yes, Sir,” she whispered.
Levi’s eyes fluttered as she slowly sank down on him, pausing as she tried to adjust. “I feel so full,” she whimpered. “The plug . . .”
“Fuck. I forgot about that,” he groaned.
“Keep going,” I encouraged. “At your own pace.”
She huffed as she worked his cock inside her. Even without the plug, it was a challenge to take all of him. But with that added fullness to her ass, I knew it made it even more so.
And made it even hotter too.
I stroked my cock as I watched her pussy spread around him, licking her off my lips.
“Fuck,” Levi gasped. “Fuck. She feels so good. I needed her.”
“I know you did,” I murmured.
I rolled to the side and reached for the kink bag, dragging it closer. I pulled out the bottle of lube and a condom, tearing open the foil and pulling it on quickly.
I needed to be inside her.
I needed to know what it’d feel like to take her at the same time as Levi.
Avery moaned as I pushed her down against him, her head resting on his chest. I slowly pulled the plug free and set it to the side, studying her ass and how fucking hot she looked right now.
Was I dreaming? I’d thought about this for so long. Fuck.
I poured a generous amount of lube on my cock and then on her hole, working it around the rim and then using my fingers to push it inside her too. She whimpered as I prepped her for my cock, wondering if she’d be able to take me.
“This will be a lot,” I said. “Between the two of us, if you need to stop, or need me to slow down, or need us to do anything—you tell us. Okay?”
“Okay,” she said. “I promise. I’ve never done anything like this before.”
“You’re in good hands,” Levi whispered.
That, she was. I positioned myself behind her, guiding the head of my cock to her. I nudged her entrance, watching as the two of them went very still.
“Relax,” I said. “And for the love of god, don’t do kegels.”
She giggled, but thankfully, didn’t do kegels. I slowly pushed inside her, and Levi moaned.
“I can fucking feel you,” he hissed. “Holy shit.”
I wasn’t even halfway in yet, and it was a tight fucking fit. Avery took in several deep breaths, her muscles tensing until she remembered to make them relax. I waited, giving her time to adjust to the size of my cock alongside Levi’s.
“You’re doing so well, baby,” Levi crooned. “You feel so fucking good.”
She nodded, letting out a breathless, “Thank you.”
He kept murmuring to her.
“You’re such a liar, Levi,” I huffed as I gave her another inch.
“Liar?” he choked out.
“Yeah. You always say you’re bad at talking. And you’re not. You’re really, really not.”
Avery gasped as she took more of me. Levi rubbed the back of her head, meeting my gaze over her shoulder.
He smiled.
It was a really wholesome smile despite the filthy, hot things we were doing. Sweet. Charming.
And dammit. Dammit, I was falling for him. And he was leaving us. Soon.
I swallowed hard as I kept sliding into Avery. I blinked and realized she’d taken all of me.
All of him.
“Fuck,” I whispered. “You did it, Blue.”
“I don’t want to be congratulated, I want to be fucked,” she groaned. “I want to come again.”
She’d certainly earned it. Levi wrapped his arms around her and was the first to move, his cock pulling back slightly before pushing in deeper.
The three of us groaned together, even from the small movement. My eyes fluttered shut as I tried to take it slow.
“I’m okay,” Avery rasped. “I’m good. I’m good.”
She was the one to move this time. She shifted, our cocks pulling out and then pushing back. My hands held onto her hips as I started to thrust. Levi did too. We found a rhythm, one that was going to make me come sooner than later, but I didn’t mind.
We were all past the point of trying to hold back. Something snapped inside me and I groaned, fucking her harder.
“Good girl,” I huffed. “Fuck. You’re taking us so well. So well.”
Levi’s thrust turned faster. Needier. I was already on the edge, but with the way I could feel his cock sliding in and out of her, I wasn’t going to last too long.
Her next cry was sharper and her muscles tensed. Avery gasped as her head tipped back, her nails digging into Levi’s shoulders as she squeezed the two of us.
Feeling her come while we were inside her was what sent me over the edge. I cursed under my breath as I slammed into her one last time, coming so hard that I felt the orgasm wrap around my entire body, pleasure rushing through me.
“Fuck,” Levi rasped. “I can’t—”
His words were clipped as he came, a long groan leaving him as he tightened his arms around her, and then me too. I always forgot how fucking long his arms were, but he managed to hug the both of us as he came inside her, filling up her pussy with every drop of his cum.
The three of us were panting. I pressed my face against Avery’s back, breathing in the scent of her. My thoughts were barely able to form, every single part of me fully relaxed and . . .
Happy.
Really, really happy.
“That was as hot as I thought it was going to be,” Avery whispered.
I nodded, savoring the moment.
“If you ever want to sell the art you make from tonight, I want it,” Levi said.
A soft laugh shook her body. “Like I said. It’ll never be for sale.”