26. Zachary
CHAPTER 26
ZACHARY
It turned out Aiden’s idea of poker was of the strip variety which, based on all previous interactions with the man, should not have been a surprise.
Teo – who was two shots ahead of me – couldn’t stop giggling. I finally asked him what was so funny.
“I didn’t put on any underwear after we showered,” he attempted to whisper in my ear before grabbing my hand.
“I hope you don’t suck then.”
“That’s not true. You want me to suck every day.” He brought my hand to his mouth and sucked my pinky for a few seconds.
I grabbed one of the shots on the table and downed it. Half-drunk Teo’s idea of whispering wasn’t really quiet, and based on the smile, I was sure Malik had heard what Teo said – both times – which meant that I was going to have to be partially drunk to endure the rest of the night.
Looking around the table, the twins had assembled an interesting group, though I supposed it wasn’t on purpose. This was just who was already back – the twins, Evan, Malik, Liam, Franklin and Oliver. I was surprised Liam, Franklin and Oliver would be okay with stripping in front of other men, but with alcohol involved, anything was possible.
It was also likely that they didn’t know what they signed up for either.
20 minutes later
“Does butt sex hurt?” Franklin asked.
“Bend over and you can find out.”
Jayden practically knocked the table over, laughing at his hilarious joke. I was only buzzed – a sign of my restraint and my need to preserve all of the lives at the table. No need to lose a brother to hypothermia or some other strange accident that I'm sure the assembled men could stumble into if drunk enough.
I couldn’t imagine what their ghost would be trapped doing twenty years from now. ΚΩΚ didn’t need another scandalous death, even if Jake had brought me and Teo together.
“Shove a finger up there. Oliver’s dick can’t be bigger than that.”
“Shut the fuck up, Liam.” Oliver threw a pretzel across the table. “I bet it’s bigger than yours.”
Suddenly, my half-buzzed brain was interested in the conversation. I wasn’t imagining the tension.
Liam might actually whip it out.
“I guess the only way we’ll see is if we both lose,” Liam said with a smirk.
10 minutes later
“You guys must fuck, like, every day, right?”
“For a straight guy, you have a lot of questions about stuff gay guys do.” Malik looked smug but most of the guys turned to see Franklin’s reaction.
“Sue me! I’m curious. Blame it on Aiden’s fat cock. ”
Aiden had been the first one to lose all his clothes. He, of course, kept finding reasons to stand up and I kept glancing at his piercings. I’d never seen any before and now I was telling myself to remember to search on Google later for more photos.
“You wanna see it up close?” Aiden waved it back and forth.
“I’m gonna need more alcohol for that,” Franklin said. “Keep that monster away from me.”
5 minutes later
Malik was on Liam’s lap.
Aiden was still answering questions from Franklin and now Oliver.
Evan and Jayden left before the last hand and hadn’t returned.
And Teo had finally lost his shorts and was now completely naked.
As soon as he turned around, I saw it. The blue gemstone in between his cheeks.
I leaned forward and pinched his butt. “You’re wearing it?”
“It’s a perfect fit.” He looked over his shoulder. “Best Christmas ever.”
“Are you guys still playing?” Evan asked, walking back from who knows where.
“We’re definitely still playing,” Jayden answered, sliding in just behind him. “But it looks like we’re behind.”
In seconds, Jayden had pulled Evan’s pants down, revealing a skimpy jockstrap.
“Fuck, Jayden.”
But despite the remark, Evan didn’t pull them back up, and the evening soon became less about the poker and more about everyone getting naked.
“He’s always doing something to see my ass,” Evan admitted before taking his seat next to Teo .
20 minutes later
“Oh God, yeah, suck it, Teo.”
1 minute later
“I’m cumming!”
“Uhhh.”
“Morning, stud,” I said, giving Teo’s nipple a tiny lick.
“It smells like cum in here.”
I had to agree. “I guess we never showered.”
“Just drag me Into the bathroom and soap me up,“ Teo said, burying his face under the covers.
“We can sleep for a bit longer and then we'll shower together, or I can run a bath.”
“Oooh. I vote for bath.”
“Hmmm.” I considered that for a few seconds. “I’ll give you a bath if you make pancakes for brunch.”
Teo reemerged to kiss my forehead. “Sounds like a fair trade.”
I slipped out of the covers and started the water. It should’ve felt strange to squat in the bathroom, completely naked, searching for bath bombs underneath the sink, but ever since we made it official, naked seemed to be the default state in our room.
Another reason we decided to head back early. It was harder to be naked together when our parents were in the same home.
After moving around some of Teo’s hair care products, I found the bath bombs. ‘Tropical Oasis’ sounded like a good choice. I tested the water after dropping it in and adjusted the temperature. It was a little too warm. I should’ve realized with the amount of steam rising from the surface.
“Something smells good.”
I turned around and was greeted with the perfect view. Teo’s body was perfect, and the way he was leaning against the door frame accentuated the curve of his ass.
“You still wearing the plug?” I had just remembered.
“Maybe.”
He tried to walk to the other side of the tub, but I grabbed his wrist and dragged him into my arms. Reaching down, I felt between his cheeks.
“Someone’s still horny,” Teo said.
“I can’t help it when my boyfriend’s this hot.” My hand slid further down and confirmed my suspicions.
“Find it?”
I gave it a little push, causing Teo to thrust forward.
“Fuck.”
“You like that?” I asked, stepping back to lean against the tub. But Teo didn’t need to answer because his dick was doing it for him.
“What do you think?” He grabbed the hardening shaft and made it bounce. “Excited for the real thing. How long are you gonna make me wait for it?” He asked, sliding into the water. “Oh, that feels good.”
“I doubt it will be that much longer, and I’m sorry for being weird about it.” As soon as I joined him in the tub, he scooted over and pushed in between my legs. I wrapped my arms around him and he laid his head on my chest.
“It’s not weird. I’m horny as fuck, but I get it. I’m nervous too, but it’s not like you’re gonna just slam it in there. You’ll be gentle and it will be amazing. We’ll know when the time is right.”
I was worried I was waiting too long, but it seemed Teo was okay with it. To be honest, I didn’t think he’d have to wait much longer. Knowing my cock could be buried inside that tight hole like the gemstone buttplug was an enormous tease.
“You’re hard,” Teo said matter-of-factly.
“Yup.”
“I love that I do that for you. Thinking of how many times you must’ve been hard because of me before–and I didn’t even know it–is incredibly arousing.”
I chuckled. “You make it sound like I’m a stalker.” My fingers were lightly tracing the muscles of his shoulders.
“Well, it’s kind of true, isn’t it?”
When I hesitated to answer, Teo grabbed my hand and made it touch his dick.
“It’s not like I have a problem with it. I actually really like it.”
“That’s…good.” I swallowed. It wasn’t like he was trying to seduce me, but this conversation was making me want to bend him over the side of the tub and and fuck him. “To be blunt, I’m shocked you never noticed me checking out your ass. I’ve been staring at it ever since your team got those new shorts.”
Teo laughed. “The super short ones? From our freshman year? Oh my God, so many guys hated those. They complained their balls were gonna fall out and they all started wearing lycra underneath.”
“I know,” I admitted. “And I’m very glad you weren’t one of them. Your legs looked phenomenal and your butt looked even better.”
“Is that when you started coming to all my games?”
“Maybe,” I teased. “But yes, I jacked off many times thinking about what was underneath.”
“If we keep talking about this, I’m gonna be the one that needs to jack off.”
“Oh yeah?” I gave his dick a squeeze.
“Fuck, I’m serious.”
I nipped his ear. “We didn’t get it all out of you last night?”
“I can’t even remember last night.” Teo leaned his head back to rest on my shoulder.
“Speaking of last night, was that the most homoerotic poker game of all time? Like it was just an excuse to get naked with other dudes?”
Teo absent-mindedly played with bubbles while he answered. “ I don’t remember a lot of the game, but I do remember Aiden flopping his dick out. I don’t know, Zach. Maybe the guys were all super horny or they’re just super chill about their bodies?”
“I think they were both.”
“You see more of this kind of thing than I do, I think. Apparently, I didn’t notice you checking out my ass for the last hundred years, so my gaydar is subpar.”
“How could you not see anything? Malik was literally in Liam’s lap.”
“Really?!”
“Yeah.”
Teo was silent for a few seconds, then said, “That’s kind of hot. Do you want me to give you a lap dance later?”
I forgot everything we were talking about as I imagined Teo’s muscular body grinding to music as if he were in Magic Mike.
“I’ll take that as a yes.” Teo wiggled his ass against my still-hard cock.
Fuck. If he kept at it, all those flavored lubes Teo got me for Christmas were going to be gone in a week. I reached down to reposition my dick–it was getting a little crushed–then wrapped my arms around him again, pulling him close.
Teo sighed and I felt him relax. “Bath smells good, by the way,” he said. “Reminds me of the Caribbean, which is where we’ll be in a couple months.”
“Oh really?”
“I thought I mentioned it already. Liam’s family has a compound on Grand Cayman.”
“A compound?”
“His words, not mine.”
“Good thing I already have a passport. Do I already have a plane ticket as well?” I asked.
“Uh…Liam said it was taken care of so I didn’t ask.”
“Jesus. ”
“Do you not wanna go?”
The last thing I wanted to do was upset Teo. I was just shocked at the amount of money some of my brothers and their families had.
“No, it’s not that.” I kissed his cheek for reassurance. “It sounds lovely.”
“So you’ll come with me?”
I’ll cum with you, on you, inside you.
“Do we get our own room?”
“Of course.”
“Then I’m definitely coming.”
And fucking your brains out.