28. Zachary
CHAPTER 28
ZACHARY
“Oh, fuck!”
I woke up and could tell that Teo wasn’t in bed with me.
“Fuck me! Harder!”
What the fuck?!
That was Teo’s voice, but my mind couldn’t process what was happening until I turned a light on.
Teo was in his bed, on all fours and…getting fucked?
“Seriously?”
Teo threw his head back and glanced my way. “What? It’s just Jake.”
No fucking way.
My dick betrayed me, hardening at the sight of Teo bracing himself against his headboard.
“You gonna stare at us or get that big dick over here?”
He didn’t have to ask me twice. If Jake thought he could pop my guy's cherry, he had a…well…he was already dead, so I wasn't much of a threat.
I closed the distance and pulled the blanket off Teo's body.
“Jake? You there?”
“What? You don’t believe me?”
Jake didn’t answer so I grabbed Teo’s ass and pulled it towards the side of the bed.
There was Teo’s hole. It was nice and tight, and definitely not gaped open.
“You little brat.” I spanked each perfect cheek.
“Fuck, do that again.” When I just stood there, he continued, “I swear he was right here, plowing away.”
“Hand me the goddamn lube.”
“Oh, fuck!”
“You like that?” I asked, knowing the answer.
Teo's smile said it all. I slowly slid my full length inside of him again.
“Harder, Zach. Please”
I couldn’t for the life of me think why I had waited. His hole felt amazing.
Plus, Teo was taking me like a champ.
Like a slut.
“Fuck yeah. Finally.”
And he clearly wanted it.
I threaded my fingers into his hair and grabbed hold. Becoming less and less gentle, the slap of our bodies meeting filled the room.
“Was it worth the wait, cupcake?”
Teo’s back was arched, enough that I could see his blissed-out face.
“God, yes.”
I kept pumping, but the sensations were almost overwhelming. Teo’s mouth was hot, but this was different.
“You’re too tight,” I said, slowing down. I moved a hand to his back to hold myself up. These muscles hadn’t been used this way before and the last thing I needed was to cramp up during our first fuck.
“That’s–fuck. That’s a bad thing?”
“I'm gonna cum if I keep up this pace.”
“Isn’t that the idea?”
I felt his hole squeeze my cock and shuddered at the sensation it created. “I meant I’m gonna cum in a minute or two. I’m…I’m not gonna last long.”
“I didn't ask you to stop.” He slid forward, then pressed back against my body, sliding my cock all the way inside him. “We have the rest of our lives to fuck, Zach. I think we'll manage.”
I didn't know what to say. His eagerness to get railed was the hottest thing I’d ever seen. But I didn’t need to say anything. Teo made the decision for us. He pulled off of me and flipped over, throwing his legs up and catching them behind the knees.
“I want to watch you fuck me.”
Fuck.
“I can do that,” I said, moving forward to kneel on the bed and line up with this hole.
“More lube first.” Teo grabbed the bottle and handed it to me.
I slicked up my shaft and pressed a little into his hole with my finger before tossing it back on the bed.
“Now get that fuckin’ dick back to work and let’s cum–ohhhh!” Teo half-screamed when I slid back inside of him. “Fuck yes!”
I was half worried someone would think I was hurting him and break down our door, but if they could hear him scream, they could also hear his dirty talk.
“Fuck, Zach. You’re so fucking huge.” He wrapped his legs around me and squeezed, pulling me towards him. “Pound the cum out of me!”
With each thrust, I lost myself. He was so into it and it made it that much better for me. Although I could tell he was struggling to stroke himself and hold up both legs .
“Here, let me,” I said, wrapping my lube-covered hand around his glistening cock.
“Yes! Thank you!”
It was sheer porn at this point and neither of us cared.
“Take my big dick, jockboy.”
“Harder, Zach! I’m close.”
A few seconds later, Teo just started repeating ‘fuck’ over and over until he threw his head back in silence and flexed every muscle he had. I kept fucking him, but watched in awe as thick ropes of cum blasted out of his dick and onto his abs.
With each fresh burst of jizz, I felt a different sensation around my own dick as Teo’s hole tightened and flexed.
I lost it.
“I’m cumming, Teo!”
I slammed forward as I felt the first burst of cum pulse out.
Teo grabbed my arms, his eyes once again locked with mine. “Give it to me, Zach.”
Another slam.
“Yes!”
He was wearing the biggest of smiles now as my orgasm finished and we started the quick descent back to reality.
“Fuck, Teo.” I leaned forward, putting the weight on my arms.
“You can say that again.” He pulled me down, close enough to give him a kiss. “And do it again too, please.”
“I have some free time in”–I pretended to look at a non-existent watch–“twenty minutes.”
“I’ll be there.”
“Remember that time you didn’t want to take a bath and ran out the front door naked?” Teo asked.
“What made you think of that? ”
We were in bed – I thought we were trying to fall asleep, though it seemed that post-fuck Teo was a bit chatty.
“Uh, you’re naked now and I was thinking about the first time I ever saw you naked. It was that day.”
“You were there?”
“I was coming over to ask you to come to the playground. I didn’t make it to the front door because I saw you running down the walkway.”
I groaned. “I remember now. I was so embarrassed when I saw you I ran straight back inside.”
“Why didn't you want to take a bath again?”
“No idea,” I answered. “I don't remember that part.”
Teo was silent for a few minutes. I thought he had fallen asleep but then he asked, “When’s the first time you saw me naked?”
I didn’t even have to think. I knew the answer immediately.
“We were in the tenth grade. After gym class – I think we had just run a mile or something – you took everything off.”
“I was sweaty.”
“I was surprised.”
“I bet.” Teo chuckled. “I never got naked during a sleepover?”
“Nope. I feel like I would remember that. Saw plenty of your underwear though. I’d always go out and buy a pair of whatever brand I saw that you had.”
“Really?” I felt Teo shift beside me. In the dim light, I could tell he was propped on one elbow and looking down at me.
“Yeah. I realize now that it’s weird.”
“I don’t know. Kind of flattering, honestly. You thought I had good taste.”
I laughed. “Sure. Let’s call it that.”
Another minute of silence.
“Can I tell you something?” Teo asked.
“Sure.”
“It was really hard for me–when we were fucking-”
Here it was. I knew I had fucked this all up somehow .
“-to not tell you to pump me full of icing.”
“What?” I was so confused. Icing?
Teo nuzzled into my armpit and groaned before continuing. “I’m your little cupcake and I wanted your cream filling. Ugh, after saying it out loud, I’m glad I didn’t say it earlier.”
I withheld my laughter so I didn’t upset him. It sounded a bit ridiculous, but it was also fucking adorable.
“Next time,” I said, “just say what you’re thinking. Pumping you full of my icing sounds kind of hot and makes me want to add frosting to the frat’s shopping list.”
“Really?”
“Of course, cupcake.”
“Can I tell you something else?” Teo asked again.
“Anything.”
“I love you.”
“I love you too.” I didn’t need to think about my response at all.
“To be clear, I love you as more than friends. More than when I’ve said it before. Like, I’m not asking you to marry me or anything, but I want you to know that I have serious feelings for you.”
“ Finally! ”
“What do you mean? Finally?” Both Teo and I asked Jake.
“ I’ve been waiting for this moment all semester ,” he answered. “ I can tell it’s working. I already feel different .”
“What are you talking about?”
“ This is what I’ve been trapped here for. This was my mission. ”
“Why didn’t you tell us?” Teo asked.
“ It doesn’t work that way. ”
“How does it work then?”
We waited for an answer.
“Jake?” I called out to the darkness.
There was only the sound of our breathing.
He was gone .
“That was–”
“Weird,” I interrupted. “And as for what you said, I feel the same way. I’m sorry I didn’t come out sooner, but honestly, it was hard being in love with a straight guy.”
“Not so straight actually.”
“I didn’t know–” I couldn’t finish because Teo’s lips were on mine.
It was a short kiss but it felt different now that our feelings were out there.
“I regret not realizing sooner that my love for you was more than friendship.” Teo rested his head on my chest. I felt his hand move to my stomach, teasing my belly button.
“I always knew we had a special friendship,” I said.
“It’s just even better now that we have physical intimacy as well,” Teo added.
“Oooh, physical intimacy,” I teased. “You sound like a sex therapist.”
“We just confessed our love for each other. I was trying to be a little more romantic in the moment. At least you can fuck me now. Is that better?”
“You can say whatever you want. I’ll keep fucking you.” I leaned over to turn on the light and pulled my nightstand drawer open to grab something. I handed the piece of paper to Teo.
“What’s this?”
“Open it.”
Teo read it aloud. “ I had a great time . This is…my handwriting?”
“Yup,” I admitted. “You’re not the only sentimental romantic here. I saved it–”
“After my playoff game, when we got drunk and I left you at the hotel,” Teo finished for me. “It’s cute that you have this.”
“What can I say? I’m just a super cute guy who also had a great time that night.”
“And who loves me. ”
“That too.”
Teo put the note down, turned the light off and snuggled back against my torso.
“I’m excited for what the future brings,” he said.
“Like being done with Calculus or spring break?” I asked.
“Well, I’m excited for those things but I meant us. Our future. We’ve known each other for years but now it’s so much better.”
I thought about our future together and remembered an earlier conversation.
“We’re going to the local shelter and finding a mutt that wants us.”
“What?”
“In the future,” I explained. “You said your dad was expecting you to find a girl at Middleton, start a career, buy a house, get a golden retriever, have kids. Well, I’m gonna say it now. I love golden retrievers but I don’t want a specific breed. We’ll take the one that picks us.”
“Some context next time, please.”
I chuckled then apologized.
“I forgive you,” Teo teased. “And that sounds fine to me, but maybe we can get a head start?”
“What do you mean?” I asked.
“Middleton has a shelter. Let’s go look tomorrow.”
“Really? Is that allowed?”
“I do know the vice president of the frat.”
“Do you think I should try to sleep with him to get him on our side?” I asked.
“Yes, that should definitely be our strategy,” Teo answered. “I heard he likes doggy style.”
“He’s not the only one.”