Chapter 54
OCTOBER 25 – SATURDAY 8:03 PM
L iam
Ren shivered and tilted her head for me when I nuzzled her neck.
“Such a good little rabbit.”
She was still tense but for a totally different reason than earlier. Placing soft kisses on her skin all the way up her throat and along her jaw to her lips, I captured her sweetness as she melted for me.
Reaching out with one hand, I turned the doorknob without looking and scooped her off the counter as it popped open. Ren wrapped her arms around my neck, and I smiled as she took control. She didn’t even realize she did it, and while it was against the rules, there was something about how it happened when we were together that didn’t bother me at all.
“Looks like you’re feeling better,” Theo said.
Ren broke the kiss and blushed as I sat her on her feet.
“I am.”
Theo stood and this was the first time I got to experience how they were together. Until this very moment, I wasn’t sure how I would feel. But the way Theo wrapped his hand around the back of her neck and drew her in made me…hot.
She sucked Theo’s bottom lip into her mouth, and I realized that there was absolutely nothing about my little rabbit that wasn’t perfect. She was beautiful, unique, and pure.
As hard as I tried, the only flaw I could find was that she was too kind-hearted. She wanted to help everyone, and that was why she needed us. We could and would get our hands dirty, but she would keep us pushing for what was right. She wouldn’t allow us to fall prey to the same greed that destroyed so many before us.
I pulled my shirt off, and Ren looked at me. Her eyes were pure fire until she spotted the bandage on my arm.
“What happened,” Ren asked quietly. Her concern was evident in every feature as she reached for my hand.
“Lawrence, but I’ll be fine.”
I ran my knuckles down her cheek, and the corner of my mouth turned up as she glared at the bandage like she was thinking of all the ways she wanted him to die.
“Trust me. I hardly feel it, and no, I’m not showing you tonight. Erase him from your mind. Thoughts of him don’t belong in this place.”
“He did that yesterday? When you, Nash, and Myles were gone all day.” I nodded. “He needs to be in a deep, dark hole.”
“He will be, but you don’t need to worry about that right now.”
Walking over to the fridge, I grabbed water and then sat down in the large leather chair next to the empty fireplace and pointed my finger between the two of them.
“I want a show. Carry on.”
Theo caught on quickly and kissed Ren again. He grabbed her hair and bent her back while she clung to the front of his shirt to stay upright. Fuck they were a picture. Ren’s mouth hung open, and her eyes closed as Theo trailed his tongue down her throat and kissed the base of her neck. A soft moan escaped her lips as he released his grip on her hair.
It hung in long waves like an icy waterfall, and the craving to wrap it around my fist was strong. Theo slowly straightened with Ren in his arms. They looked like they were caught in the throws of a sensual dance as he took a step forward, and she took one back. He didn’t stop until her back was pressed up against the wall. I licked my lips, burning with envy.
He drew her hands above her head and then followed it with her hoodie that he tossed on the couch.
“I love it when you shiver like that,” Theo growled against Ren’s lips.
My jeans tightened, watching his dominance over her. I’d been teaching him a little too well it seemed. Theo effortlessly took control of the entire situation. In a few moves, he had Ren standing before us in a sexy little thong and bra. Without a single word, Ren bent backward over the arm of the couch as Theo got on his knees between her thighs.
I sucked in a deep breath to keep myself in check as Theo pulled the fabric out of the way and gave me an unobstructed view of his tongue working Ren over. I couldn’t see her face, but the little moans were like a siren’s call to all my senses.
Grabbing the remote off the small table beside me, I hit the button for the television and flipped through music stations until I found one that set the mood. The smooth yet dark and sexy instrumental selection filled the room and added to Ren’s whimpers.
“Stop, but don’t move.”
Theo obeyed beautifully while Ren struggled. I sipped my water and watched her knuckles turn bright white as she gripped the cushion.
“Continue.”
“Oh god,” Ren said.
“Stop. Little Rabbit, you’re not allowed to make another sound until I say.”
Her sassy attitude permeated the air, though she said nothing.
“Don’t sass me,” I said for good measure and then softly chuckled as she swore. It was barely audible over the music, but I caught it.
“Theo?”
He looked at me, his green eyes full of devious desire. I loved seeing this part of him alive and shining—it made me fucking smile.
“Our little rabbit doesn’t seem to know the meaning of hold still or keep quiet. Please go grab the bag of toys.” Theo smirked. “And take off your shirt,” I ordered.
He stared me down as he grabbed the bottom of his black t-shirt and slowly peeled it off over his head. His abs were taut, his hair messy, and with the black jeans, he looked badass. Fuck me…between the two of them, I was being tested.
Theo walked out of the room, his back and ass flexing as I watched him. He returned a moment later with my black bag that had a few things I’d brought from home. He pulled each item out and laid them on the coffee table beside Ren. She couldn’t tell what any of them were because I stored my toys in separate leather sheaths that were tied closed. For all she knew, they were knives, cock rings, and everything in between. The last item he removed from the bag was a tube of lube. Theo knew my preferred order and would’ve laid the items out accordingly. I pointed to the sleeve that housed ten different sizes of butt plugs. These weren’t the exotic set that I used on Theo. This was a brand-new training set, just for my little rabbit.
We would have her together eventually, but that took time and patience. Just the thought of both of us fucking her as she screamed sent a shiver racing down my spine.
“Um….” Ren started as Theo unwrapped the black leather to show off the shiny silver plugs.
“Quiet, Little Rabbit.”
Theo gingerly ran his fingers over them as he teased Ren. He stopped on the largest and smiled. Annoyed that I couldn’t see her facial expressions, I took another swig of the water before standing and walking closer. Ren’s hair was splayed out over the couch, her chest heaving as she stared at Theo, her face easily readable. She looked caught between excited and terrified.
“The smallest,” I said, and her eyes darted up to mine.
Stepping around the table, I squatted down and smoothed some of the wild strands of hair away from her face. I saw Theo out of the corner of my eye as he pulled the tiny plug and held it in his palm.
Ren licked her lips and looked away, but I tapped her arm and pointed to my face.
“You keep your eyes on me until I say otherwise.” She nodded. “Are you scared?” She nodded again. “Don’t be. Theo knows what he’s doing, and he won’t hurt you. It will feel…unusual until you get used to the sensation.” She licked her lips, running the bottom one through her teeth. “By the time you’ve worked up to the large size, you’ll be begging us to fuck you hard, and I can guarantee that you’ll be screaming our names.”
“Close your eyes,” I said, running my hand gently from her forehead down to her mouth, over and over until they stayed shut, and she began to take regular breaths once more. Leaning in close to her ear, I growled. She sucked in a ragged breath, and her body arched from the sensual sound that awakened all of her primal instincts to run.
While Ren was distracted, I glanced at Theo. He nodded that he was ready, and I gave him the signal as my fingers trailed down her arm to her fingers.
“Breathe, Little Rabbit, and focus on my touch,” I said, tracing her stomach and up her chest between her breasts. “You’re going to feel a little bit of pressure, but just relax. Right now,” I said, and she shuddered. She held her breath, and the moment she released it, I knew it was all the way in. “That’s it. It’s in.”
Goosebumps rose where my fingers had been. Every twitch of Ren’s body and flinch of her facial expression told me exactly how she was feeling.
This was what got me off and turned me on more than anything. The ability to read another so easily and to inflict arousal with just a touch was powerful. Forget money and fear. This was what I craved. Possessing the skills that made another willingly hand over their body and mind to you was a rush. It came with immense responsibility, but there was nothing I loved more than holding Theo’s, and now Ren’s, needs in the palm of my hand.
“Continue feasting on our little rabbit,” I said, and Ren jerked as Theo got to work.
Her eyes snapped open as I caressed her hard nipples, the little peaks pushing the lacy material. Ren’s breathing picked up, and her plump lips begged to be kissed. As hard as she tried, she couldn’t hold perfectly still. I could just see Theo’s eyes between her legs and knew exactly how talented he was with that tongue.
“Don’t come, Little Rabbit. If you do, I’ll have no choice but to tan your sexy little ass,” I groaned in her ear. “On second thought…come. My palm is itching to redden your skin and then fuck you hard.”
Ren’s nostrils flared, and her eyes hardened as she silently accepted the challenge head-on.
“Oh fuck, does that feel good? I bet it does. His hot tongue swirling around your clit and plunging deep inside of you,” I softly said, and Ren shivered.
Inch by inch, I slid the straps of her bra off her shoulders until I was able to fold the lace away from my prize.
“Theo.”
He stopped and Ren’s body went slack. She’d been right there on the edge.
“Is your pussy begging for that sweet release, Little Rabbit?”
Ren turned her head, her lips close to mine, but her eyes were filled with a fiery passion that only came when your body was tormented with desire. She opened her mouth to answer, but I touched my finger to the lush, softness of her lips, shook my head, and then turned to Theo.
“Yes, Sir,” he said, and my cock throbbed with those two little words that were said every day a million times. But they meant so much more.
“Grab the clit stimulator, the curved one with the vibrator attached.”
Theo moved quickly to prep the toy. I held out my hand, and he gave me the remote. Ren’s curiosity flared in her eyes as she watched us.
“Do you know what this is?” She shook her head. “You’re about to find out. Trust me, you’re going to want to come. Your body will beg you to let go. You’ll ache all over and throb between your thighs, but you won’t…not until I give you permission.”
My little rabbit moaned as Theo pushed the thick vibrator inside her and then attached the stimulator. It acted like a miniature simulation of someone sucking her clit. As soon as it was in place, I looked at Theo and he stood.
The large bulge in the front of his jeans drew my attention. He’d gotten amazingly good at hiding the ache, but I knew he was just as pent up as Ren.
“Take your jeans off and make sure we can both see you,” I said.
Theo’s fingers worked swiftly on the button and zipper of his jeans. Bending over, he pulled them off and kicked them aside. He was commando, just how I liked him. There was nothing as amusing as grabbing him when he least expected it and dragging him into an empty classroom or storage area.
“Come here. I want the little rabbit to watch as you stroke your cock.”
My mouth watered as his hand ran up the entire length of his shaft and back down. He would look incredible with a piercing…or two.
“You ready, Little Rabbit? You can answer.”
“Yes, Sir,” she panted.
Everything was already getting to her, and I wanted to see how much more she could take before breaking.
“Good girl…now keep your eyes on his cock and picture him being the one fucking you. Can you do that for me, Little Rabbit? Can you be a good fucking girl?”
“Yes, Sir,” she whispered this time and then bit her lip.
Rolling her nipple between my fingers, she moaned, and I hit the vibration button. Ren’s eyes popped open, and she convulsed as I added the sucking action. But the sexiest thing I’d ever seen was when her entire body bowed, pushing her breast into my palm as I turned on the self-propelled fucking feature. We were still on level one, but she was having difficulty breathing through the extreme sensations.
After a few minutes, she relaxed a tiny bit, and I upped the speed to level two. Ren gritted her teeth like she was in pain as she tried to resist the pull of her orgasm.
“Don’t close your eyes, Little Rabbit. Watch Theo stroke himself while he watches you.”
Ren’s head rolled from side to side, sweat beading on her forehead.
“Look at him. That’s a direct order.”
Half-lidded with ecstasy, she gazed at Theo. The ring I’d put on before dinner tightened as my cock thickened to full size with no relief tucked inside my jeans. The throbbing was like its own heartbeat, the need ever-increasing.
“Tell me how that feels.”
“So…so…so good,” Ren stuttered out.
I moved out of the way and directed Theo where to stand.
“Little Rabbit, be a good girl and stroke his cock for him. Theo’s arm is tired,” I said, walking around to watch the toys work.
The thick purple dildo thrust in and out a couple of inches at a time as it buzzed. I slid my hands down her thighs and ran my finger through her wet lips. Glancing away from the pleasure torture, I watched as Ren’s hand on Theo worked in time with the vibrator fucking her. His head was back, and his eyes were closed while the swollen tip of his dick announced that he was close to coming as well.
Ren’s eyes locked onto the device when I held up the remote. She shook her head. A horrified expression crossed her face as I moved my thumb over to the little levels button.
“You still can’t come…but you can yell,” I said and hit the button.
“Fuuuuuuucccccccccck!”
Ren’s legs straightened and shook as the dildo went faster. “Oh god, oh god, Liam…please…please…I can’t.”
“You can.”
I hit the off button, and she cried out in frustration.
“Don’t worry about me. Lick just the tip of Theo’s cock.”
Grabbing the back of the couch, Theo lowered himself closer to her mouth. Watching them was as good as an aphrodisiac. Their desperation for release perfumed the air.
“Good girl. Now suck the head of his cock into your mouth and moan.”
Theo’s legs nearly buckled as she did.
“Excellent, keep going. I’m turning this back on.”
She shouldn’t expect warnings going forward, but tonight was just night one.
The toy picked up where it left off, right on level four, and if I hadn’t been standing between her legs, she would’ve squeezed them together.
The dual moaning got louder and louder, their faces twisted in delicious agony as I undid my jeans and stepped out of them. Neither of them noticed my cock bouncing in the air as a line of precum trickled down the side.
“Stop,” I said, impressed that they’d both managed to hang on, even if it wasn’t by much.
Ren whimpered, and her hips bucked up like her body had a mind of its own.
“Let him go,” I ordered.
Ren released Theo as I gently removed the vibrator but left the butt plug in place.
“Theo, come here.”
He paused before me, and I grabbed him, crashing our lips together. He groped my shaft, breaking the rules, and I groaned into his mouth. Fuck, I loved the feel of his hands on me.
“You’re going to get into trouble for that,” I said.
“I’m counting on it,” he growled.
“You’re a lot more trouble as a switch,” I said, smirking as he smiled.
“I really am. You love it, even if you don’t want to admit it. Just like how you’re enjoying this far more than you ever thought possible,” Theo said, and he wasn’t wrong.
I arched my eyebrow at him and nodded at Ren.
“Get between her legs. Fuck her and bend over. Your ass is mine,” I said, my teeth grinding together.
“Little Rabbit, are you still with us, or did you pass out?”
“I’m still awake, Sir,” she said, but her voice was breathless and about to be a whole lot more.
“You can come on Theo. But just know…you’ll be coming a minimum of three times before the night is out.”
Theo grabbed her ass, pulling her hips higher onto the arm of the couch, and sank balls deep.
“Fuck,” they swore together.
Picking up the lube, I slathered myself and then spread more between Theo’s ass cheeks. He hummed as I rubbed my finger around the base of the very large plug that he had put in before they left Wayward. I gently pulled it out, a little jealous that he’d ridden his motorcycle here and had felt the subtle vibration the whole time.
He grunted as the last of it slipped out. I set it aside and got into position.
“I set the pace,” I commanded, teasing Theo’s ass with the tip of my cock.
It was much quicker to push all the way in with the pre-prep, but I held still, enjoying the feel of him. Pulling out and pushing in, I found a rhythm that suited me. A few thrusts later, Ren screamed as she came.
Theo was shaking, but I hadn’t given him permission to come yet. Wrapping my hand around his throat, I squeezed. He leaned back into me, eyes closed as his cock pumped into Ren.
“You’re such a good boy. Tell me how you like that,” I ordered.
“I fucking love it, Sir,” he said, hissing as I picked up the pace and gripped his throat tighter. He trusted me completely and didn’t fight, which fed my craving for control.
“Do you want to come?”
“Yes, Sir.”
“You want your cock to release a load in her while I pound into your ass,” I snarled in his ear and felt him quake against me before he spoke.
“Fuck yes, Sir.”
“Then do it. Come for me.”
I bit down on the skin at the crook of his neck and let loose. I fucked him hard and fast, driving him deeper into our little rabbit. His hands dug into her ass to hold her steady, making his arms flex with the effort.
With a guttural yell, Theo came. Every muscle in his body tightened, including his ass around my cock. Ren screamed again, calling out our names. I didn’t want to hold off and instead chose to enjoy the moment with them. There was plenty of time to drive them both to the edge of insanity.
My eyes closed as I came, slamming him into Ren and continuing the orgasm circle until I was drained.
Hugging Theo, I caught my breath and let the euphoric feeling flow through my body.
“I love you,” I whispered. “Both of you.”
“I love you, too,” they said together, making me warm all over.
“That’s good because I’m ready for round two,” I said and smirked as my cock twitched, looking for more.