21. Atlas
21
atlas
Theo, Colt and I never really dated, we went from friends to lovers to partners in a matter of weeks. While we did get to know each other, we never really did the whole dating thing. So, this date with Nova fulfilled a part of me I didn’t know I had been missing.
“Well, how did you meet?” Nova asked, as she twirled her fork with pasta.
I looked at Theo and Colt barely able to hide my smile.
Nova looked between us. “This looks like a good story.”
“Colt and I met on a hook-up app, fucked my brains out and I met Theo in college,” Atlas said. “He saw me getting roughed up by a few players and stepped in.”
“So, you got fucked and then saved,” Nova smirked. “Sounds like a great meet-cute.”
I laughed as Theo shook his head and Colt chuckled.
“Well, after the meet-cute, they really saved me,” I said, getting serious. “It was late at night when these guys decided to fuck with me again.”
“They cornered him and tried to…” Colt’s voice trailed off.
“What the fuck?” Nova snarled.
“I was really young when I went to college and medical school, so I was always an easy target.” I shrugged and took a bite of my food.
“They were closeted assholes,” Colt growled.
“So, Theo and Colt taught them a lesson,” I said, looking at my men.
“Colt did most of the teaching, I hit one guy and then made sure Atlas was ok,” Theo said.
“You look like a lover instead of a fighter.” Nova grinned at him.
“I’m an exceptional lover,” Theo flirted back.
Nova's eyes grew wide as she blushed. “So, after that, you guys banged it out?”
I shook my head, chuckling.
“After that, I would walk him everywhere I could and at night Colt would pick him up,” Theo said. “I would see Colt around and I started saying hello. I pushed myself to talk to him more and he never judged me.”
“Then one night, Theo joined us and surprised the hell out of us by kissing us,” Colt chuckled. “He said he liked us and maybe we could hang out and have sex next time.”
“Theo!” Nova looked shocked.
“I was attracted to them, and I thought telling them was the best plan of action,” Theo shrugged.
I loved his honesty.
“This quiet guy asking to sleep with us was adorable and I thought, fuck it.” I looked over at Theo. “Surprisingly, we had to convince Colt for a threesome. Our bad boy was more reserved, he watched us until he snapped and well, we all had sex together. Little did we know we popped Theo’s cherry on many things that night.”
“Wow, I didn't expect Theo to be the one to bring you guys together,” Nova said, pushing her plate away.
“I know what I want.” Theo shrugged, glancing at Nova.
I should have seen it for what it was worth. He had always been interested in her, he was quiet and shy until he wasn’t.
The tension between us was thick.
“So, then you just started dating?” Nova asked, taking a sip of her drink.
“You could say that. These two were relentless and I was too weak to stay away even after I was—.” Colt’s voice trailed off.
Nova’s brows furrowed as Colt scowled. I opened my mouth to say something to steer the conversation away, but Colt started talking.
“I was arrested with possession and the intent to sell,” he said softly. “I served a year and a half.”
Nova’s eyes grew wide.
“I grew up with a single mom and she struggled a lot. I started dealing when I got into high school to help her out because working at a grocery store wasn’t enough and the local dealer took advantage of our situation,” he said, looking down at his lap. “I got busted after I met these two and I was given a deal. I corroborated a story, and I was given a lesser sentence. If I didn’t have these two, I probably wouldn’t have escaped that life.”
Colt had never told another soul this and sometimes I forgot he was an ex-felon.
“We do some crazy things for love.” Nova grabbed his hand. “I’m sorry you had to resort to dealing.”
Colt studied her for a moment, I almost thought he might lash out at her. He’s always had unresolved anger issues.
“Thank you,” he said, looking at their hands, then looking back at her. “I thought you should know who you had around your daughter.”
I never thought about his past affecting this. My mind scrambled to come to his defense when she spoke.
“Thank you for telling me,” she said. “I… can’t say that it doesn’t make me nervous, but…”
“I've left that life behind, I’m not that man anymore,” he said quickly. “I would never do anything or bring anything home to hurt Sol.”
“He’s more than his past,” Theo added.
“I know,” she murmured. “Just know that she’s my priority and if we feel unsafe?—”
“If anything happens, I will remove myself,” he said quickly. “But that life is behind me. I want no part of it. I have a quaint little ranch life with people I love and care about. I would never jeopardize that.”
“He’s been great since we left Texas.” I grabbed her hand, but she was too focused on Colt.
They stared at each other, something was happening between them, and I felt like a voyeur. I glanced at Theo who was looking surprised at what was happening in front of us, like they had a history, or something had happened between them.
Colt cleared his throat, breaking their spell.
“Thank you for telling me.” She leaned forward, kissing his cheek.
Colt’s demeanor changed. I could see his arousal as he turned his face, capturing her mouth in a kiss. She moaned a little too loudly, and I cleared my throat to remind them we were in public.
They pulled away, a little breathless.
“Please don’t hurt us,” Nova whispered, looking at each of us.
I wanted to make that promise, but I held back.
“We will do everything in our power to do things right,” Theo said.
While it wasn’t a promise, I saw that it eased her worry a little. We spent the rest of the dinner talking about lighter topics, and I felt us ease into something that felt like the promise of tomorrow.
We walked out of the restaurant as Colt talked about getting used to working at the ranch and how none of the animals liked him. Nova’s laugh was carefree, and it was a good look on her. I walked quickly to open her door so I could sit in the back with her and as she slid in Theo got into the back from the other side.
I glared at him as Nova laughed.
“You got to ride with me on the way here,” she smirked.
I huffed, and closed her door as I went to the front of the car.
“Damn, am I chopped liver already?” Colt chuckled, turning the car on.
“Nah, baby, you know I love you,” I said, laying my hand on his thigh close to his cock.
He narrowed his eyes on me, but smiled, looking more relaxed than I had seen him in a long time. I wondered how heavily his past had been weighing on him concerning the girls.
The drive back made me sleepy. The rhythm of the car, Colt’s warmth next to me and the alcohol were the perfect combo, until I heard a small sigh and groan. My head whipped back so fast that I made myself dizzy.
Theo was pulling Nova to him so he could deepen the kiss. She cupped his face moving one hand to his hair as he kneaded her thigh. They kissed passionately, hands roaming everywhere when I felt a brush against my cock.
“They look good together,” Colt murmured.
I nodded dumbfounded.
“Let me return the favor,” Nova moaned.
Colt and my gaze snapped back to them.
“I want to taste you again,” he groaned.
A whine escaped me.
“We should wait till we get to the house,” Colt suggested.
“I don’t have Stellar all night,” Nova panted, as Theo kissed down her neck.
“Then we better get started,” Theo growled. “Don’t crash.”
He looked up at Colt.
“Fuck,” Colt growled, as Theo pulled Nova into his lap. “Not fair. If I had known this was gonna be the case, I would have sat back there with her, you've already tasted her.”
“Pull over, big boy,” Nova said in a sultry tone, looking over her shoulder.
“It’s too dangerous,” Theo smirked. “Keep your eyes on the road and I’ll make it up to you.”
Colt snarled as he kept driving. I leaned over to kiss Colt’s neck as I watched Theo and Nova. I couldn’t see much until Theo turned Nova around to face me. Her back was flushed against Theo as his hands roamed her body, cupping her breasts as he trailed down her dress to kissed her neck. He looked at me as he touched her, and another whine unconsciously escaped me.
“You like watching them, you dirty slut?” Colt pulled me closer. “You like seeing Theo pleasure our girl?”
I nodded.
“Words,” Colt snapped.
“Yes, I want to see her come,” I whined, locking eyes with Nova.
She leaned forward, threaded her hand into my hair and pulled me towards her. She kissed me hard, her tongue probing for entrance into my mouth. We moaned together as we kissed, and Colt rubbed my cock over my pants.
“Fuck,” Nova whimpered into my mouth.
“Is he touching your pussy?” I whispered against her mouth, as she moaned against my lips.
“Y-yes,” she muttered.
“Tell me what he is doing to you.” I adjusted myself so I could rub Colt’s cock.
“He has his finger in my pussy, fucking me slowly,” she gasped. “Two fingers now.”
“Are you wet for us?” I looked over at Theo who was biting his lip, nodding at me.
“She’s so slick,” he murmured.
“Let me taste her,” I snapped, my yearning making me impatient.
Theo’s coated finger slid inside my mouth, her sweetness made me groan with pleasure.
“Fuck, you taste?—”
Nova slammed her lips against me, tasting herself, driving me wild. Theo yanked Nova back, and opened her legs. It was hard to see, but the sounds her drenched pussy was making had me wanting to climb over the seat and join them back there. Theo pulled down the cups of her dress and bra revealing her luscious tits.
“Touch yourself as I fuck you with my fingers,” Theo growled.
“Fucking A,” Colt snarled. “I can’t believe this is happening. I should be fucking her with my fingers.”
“Pull over,” I snapped, as sex permeated the air. “We can make it quick.”
I was likely to blow with minimal effort.
“Don’t, we don’t want her to be late,” Theo groaned. “That's it, Darlin’, come on my fingers, let them hear how I make you come.”
“Fucking Theo,” Colt murmured.
“Theo,” she whimpered, as we turned into town. “I’m… I’m close.”
“Come on, Gorgeous,” Theo grunted.
I leaned over the backseat, my sanity flying out the window as I latched on to her left nipple, sucked hard while I pinched the other.
“Fuck, fuck!” she yelled as Colt turned onto the main street.
I was worried someone would see her or us, the last thing we needed was to be spotted by someone and be even more gossip for the town, but seeing her come was worth it. Theo removed his fingers, pushing them into my mouth as I cleaned them off. I moaned, licking the last bits of her off of him, when I was yanked back and Colt kissed me.
I tried to push him away but it was useless until I realized we were stopped at the light we needed to turn down the street. I deepened the kiss so he could taste her, pulling a groan from him. The light turned green as he let me go and I looked around to make sure no one saw us.
Theo and Nova talked in soft murmurs as we came up to our driveway. I was still hard as a rock when I got out of the car wondering if there was any way I could convince her to stay or to let us go with her.
Colt helped Nova out of the car. “I should spank both of you for putting that show on for us. I could have crashed.”
He kissed her, tilting her head for a better angle and I was ready to watch some spanking. He let go of Nova, reaching for Theo who met his intensity as they fought for dominance.
Nova and I whimpered while we watched them and she kissed me.
“Stay,” I said against her lips.
“I can’t,” she groaned.
“Let us go with you,” I said, trying to come up with any excuse to go with her.
She pushed me away, catching her breath.
“Sol is home, and I can’t risk letting her know about you guys,” she said, taking a deep breath.
“It’s ok, we can wait,” Colt said, kissing her softly. “Your next orgasm is mine, got it?”
“Yes,” she whimpered. “Thank you for dinner.”
She walked away from us, looked back one last time before she ran to her car. We were screwed, but thankfully I didn’t have to wait for my orgasm. The guys and I rushed into the house and released the pent-up tension. Thank god for boyfriends.