Chapter 23
“CAN CHASE HELP TUCK me in tonight?”
Butterflies fluttered in Tobias’ stomach at the excited gleam in Madison’s eyes.
Chase had the same excited gleam in his eyes too, sending the butterflies into a frenzy.
He was falling hard and fast, like a damn slap shot, and there wouldn’t be a net to catch him.
“Of course he can, Maddie-moo,” Tobias said as he grabbed Madison’s hand and cocked his head at Chase for him to follow them, which Chase did with a beaming smile.
Madison went through her bedtime routine with more zest than usual. She was showing off for Chase, showing him how awesome she was one task at a time. Tobias had never seen anyone show off by “brushing her teeth the best,” but he sure wouldn’t complain.
Once they tucked Madison in, Phil the Phoenix snuggled tightly under her arm, Tobias sat on the purple pouf by her bed, Chase kneeling beside him.
Together they read one of her many books aloud.
Tonight’s choice was The Monster at the End of This Book, and both her and Chase giggled as Grover continued to warn them against turning the page.
When it was time for lights out, Madison demanded a hug and kiss from both Tobias and Chase, and Tobias’ heart melted as he watched them embrace sweetly. Chase even popped a kiss on Phil’s head, making Madison giggle some more.
Before long, they were in the hallway, and Chase peered at him sweetly.
“Are you going to kiss me goodnight too?” he asked.
Tobias reached a hand up to Chase’s cheek, his thumb caressing his skin, and Chase leaned into it.
With his other hand, Tobias reached out and grabbed Chase’s, pulling him toward the other side of the house, not saying another word until they reached the inside of his bedroom and Tobias closed the door behind him and boxed Chase in against it.
“Just a kiss won’t be good enough,” Tobias said as he brought his lips to Chase’s.
Chase’s mouth against his lit a flame in him he had no intention of extinguishing.
All traces of sweetness were gone and the only things left were fire and passion as Chase let loose everything Tobias had been craving all day.
It wasn’t long before Chase pushed against Tobias, directing him until his legs hit his bed. Chase shoved him so his back hit the plush mattress
It was surprising they had yet to do anything inside a bedroom, let alone on any soft surface.
Both their first kiss and their first orgasms took place in his gym, and their only other time together was in his basement’s training room.
He hadn’t even gotten Chase naked yet, a mistake he needed to rectify immediately.
Luckily, Chase was on the same page as he stood at the foot of the bed, licking his lips as he eyed Tobias’ body.
Without a word, he ripped off his shirt, then slowed his movements as he reached the button of his jeans, undoing it and lowering his zipper one tooth at a time until Tobias burned with impatience.
Chase smirked as he lowered his jeans to the floor and palmed the bulge in his tight black briefs.
The only light in the room came from the moon sneaking through the window, and it highlighted every bump of Chase’s abs, every ridge of his muscles, his cheekbones popping and his eyes practically black in the dim light.
“Take off your clothes,” Chase said, a hint of dominance in his voice. Tobias didn’t want to know what would happen if he didn’t listen. Or maybe he did. But not tonight. Tonight, he wanted Chase to lead him.
I’d follow him anywhere.
Tobias rushed to remove his clothing, not worrying about finesse or sex appeal while doing it. All of his brain cells were malfunctioning at the moment thanks to the man standing at the foot of his bed, rubbing himself as he watched Tobias’ every movement.
When he was naked, Chase eyed him from head to toe, his breath stuttering at the sight.
“Fuck, you’re perfect.”
Tobias was thankful for the dim lighting and hoped it hid his blush. Did Chase own a mirror? If anyone in this room was perfect, it was Chase.
Chase’s fingers dipped under the waistband of his briefs, and he lowered them as he kept his sharp gaze on Tobias.
As Chase revealed his thick cock, Tobias gasped. Apparently, he had forgotten to breathe for too long and his body had to remind him to do it.
Once his briefs were shed, Chase crawled hungrily onto the bed and over top of him, and Tobias shuffled up the covers until his head hit his pillows.
Chase hovered over him and lifted one of his hands to softly touch Tobias’ cheek, his fingers continuing their exploration into his hair.
“Can I fuck you?” Chase asked, his voice low and desperate.
Tobias gulped before he could remember how to speak. Still, he could only manage a single word.
“Please.”
Chase smiled and dove against Tobias, their bodies colliding, skin to heated skin, their mouths meeting and their tongues tangling, their hard cocks pushed against each other.
For the love of God, please don’t come yet, Tobias begged his body.
‘I’ll try my fucking best,’ his brain answered. Thankfully, they were on the same page.
Chase broke away from their kissing and said something, but all Tobias could hear was himself begging not to come yet.
“What?” Tobias asked.
“Supplies. Do you have them?”
Tobias blinked at him.
Supplies. Supplies? What the fuck are supplies?
Chase chuckled and climbed off of him. Tobias immediately missed his warmth.
“Don’t worry, I came prepared,” Chase said as he slid off the bed and lifted his jeans off the ground, pulling two little packets out of his pocket.
Oh. Supplies.
It had been way too fucking long for him.
Chase put one knee on the bed and stroked his cock as he gazed at Tobias. Every moment apart from him had his blood heating until he was desperate to get Chase inside of him.
After what felt like forever, Chase leaned forward until his hot breath tickled Tobias’ dick.
Chase gave the tip a sweet kiss and reached under Tobias’ legs, pushing them up toward his chest, putting him on full display.
Tobias didn’t have time for bashfulness as Chase slid his lips along his cock, his balls, his body shivering when cool breath reached his hole.
Chase’s tongue teased at his rim, and Tobias choked back a shout. The last thing he wanted to do was wake everyone in the house, so he held his forearm against his mouth to muffle his yells.
Tobias had never been rimmed before. He’d never had the chance with his hookups because he never let them get close enough to do something so intimate.
Chase gave him a prime demonstration of everything Tobias had been missing by denying himself for so long.
And he wasn’t only thinking about rimming. He’d missed out on this closeness with another person. On completely letting himself go with someone.
Tobias had never had something like that before, and he sure as hell didn’t want to lose it now.
The only problem was he was getting dangerously close to coming, and Chase hadn’t even gotten inside him yet.
It felt too damn good, and Tobias reached down to squeeze the base of his cock to try to stave off his orgasm.
“Fuck, Chase, you gotta stop,” he breathed. “I don’t want to come until you’re deep in me.”
Chase lifted his head from between Tobias’ legs, his smile disarming Tobias completely as he gazed at the wetness around his mouth.
Chase wiped it away with one hand and grabbed one of the packets with the other, ripping it open and sitting on his heels while smiling at Tobias and rolling the condom on himself achingly slowly.
Chase grabbed the second packet and squeezed lube onto his fingers and his sheathed cock.
“We wouldn’t want that,” Chase said smugly.
Tobias didn’t care. Chase had earned every ounce of smugness.
“Don’t worry, Tobias. I’m gonna make you feel amazing.”
“You already have,” Tobias rasped, and Chase’s smile grew.
When Chase’s fingers sank into Tobias’ hole, his eyes snapped shut and he threw his head back against the pillow.
Instead of pegging his prostate, Chase scissored his fingers, opening him and teasing him.
He wasn’t sure how many fingers were inside him, but he could tell Chase was being careful and making sure Tobias wouldn’t feel pain.
“You ready for me?” Chase asked, and Tobias’ gaze swung to him. He sat back on his heels, looking like a debauched porn star, his hair rumpled and his chest heaving in anticipation.
Tobias stuck with his new favorite word. “Please.”
Chase leaned forward, and Tobias watched as he lined up his cock, pushing forward until Chase sank inside him, one glorious inch at a time.
When Chase’s hips met Tobias’ ass, Chase breathed heavily.
“You okay?” Chase asked.
“Yes, please move. Get me out of my head.”
Chase didn’t say anything, just fell against Tobias’ body, bringing their mouths together in a ferocious kiss Tobias wanted to last forever.
He was pleasantly surprised at how amazing it felt to kiss Chase. The man had thin lips, but he moved them perfectly against Tobias’, making him forget anything else existed outside of the two of them.
As they kissed, Chase started moving in and out of Tobias’ body, slowly gaining speed with every thrust.
Chase reached for one of Tobias’ thighs and hitched it over his arm. The new angle had Chase hitting Tobias’ prostate dead-on on every pass, and Tobias flew toward his release.
Tobias wasn’t even aware of what sounds he made, too distracted by Chase’s mouth pressed against his, their tongues dueling as Chase’s hips pistoned against him.
“Tell me you’re close,” Chase said.
“Yes, yes, make me come.”
Chase’s fingers settled around one of his nipples, Chase’s abs rubbing against Tobias’ hard cock. A moment later Tobias burst between them, stars blinking behind his tightly closed eyes.
He was mostly aware of Chase’s hips losing their rhythm, his thrusts quickening as Chase buried his face against Tobias’ shoulder. Chase bit it to quiet his grunts and brought Tobias’ focus back to the bedroom.