Chapter 18 #2
She took her time letting me enter her, her walls tightening around me when I pushed farther.
She clutched my pecs, her hair wild and all over the place, and I couldn’t get enough.
I held on to her hips and helped her figure out the pace—slow, then fast, hard, then soft.
We found it and sweat formed between our smooth skin. “Give me your mouth.”
She giggled and lowered her upper body so I could kiss the hell out of her. Her nipples tickled my chest and I used a free hand to pinch one, then the other, and she bucked against me. “Tanner, I-I…”
“Want do you need?”
“Touch me, down there.”
I did and she cried out my name not long after, her hair falling in my face as the tingle of an orgasm started in the base of my spine.
She arched her hips, giving me a better angle, and fuck, that did it.
Four more thrusts, and I spilled into her, kissing her neck and palming her ass in my hands. Heaven.
She. Felt. Like. Heaven.
“Kenzie, wow. Just…” I couldn’t finish. My body hummed with the lingering pleasure and I made sure to lift her off me carefully, setting her next to me. “I’m spent. One hundred percent spent.”
“Samesies.”
I chuckled and patted her leg before cleaning myself up.
When I returned to my room, it startled me to see her lying there, in my bed, and I didn’t have the urge to run her out.
I always wanted hook-ups gone after it was over.
There wasn’t anything I cared to talk about with them, but Kenzie…
I couldn’t decide what to bring up first. The fact that I would miss her for the next week, that I didn’t know what that meant, or the issue of making our… situation…exclusive.
She saw me staring at her and sat up. “Shit, you don’t like it when they linger.” She stood, covering her boobs with her hands, but before she’d taken three steps, I had my arms around her, carrying her back to the bed. “Uh, Tanner, whatcha doing?”
“I’d prefer if you stayed.”
“I’d prefer that, too.”
I couldn’t explain the flutter in my chest when she said those words and I didn’t need to. “I’d offer you a shirt, but I like you naked.”
“Clothes waste time.”
“God, you’re incredible.” I laughed and pushed back the covers so we could get under them. She did, and something about her kind and carefree expression pulled at my heartstrings. I continued to stare at her, when she twisted her mouth into a smirk. “What’s that look for?”
“Just thinking I better add a check to my list and change it to eighteen.”
“Uh, no.” I turned onto my side, resting my head on my hand and dragging my fingers down her neck, collarbone, and ending on the curve of her breast. “Those times were specifically in your bedroom. Not mine.”
“Really now?” she asked, scrunching her nose in the cutest fucking way. “I don’t remember stating those rules.”
“We did. You must’ve forgotten when I brought your clit to my mouth. Easy mistake. I’ll forgive it this time.”
“You’re so kind,” she mumbled, scooting closer to me so our faces were a breath apart. “We never got around to talking about my list—another easy mistake—but what did you want to talk about?”
Oh, right.
“I wanted to make sure—” Footsteps headed up the stairs, the heavy thud definitely not Greta’s. “Shit. Just in case go—”
Knock. “TJ, you decent?” Aaron.
Kenzie had a look of horror on her face and I brought my finger up to her lips and mouthed, go to the bathroom. She nodded, her eyes larger than I had ever seen them, and trod carefully across the floor, her curvy ass distracting me for a second.
“TJ?”
“Uh, yeah. Hold on.” I scrambled to find the nearest pair of shorts and threw them on. Kenzie got inside the bathroom, shutting the door to my side without making a sound, just as Aaron walked in. “Thanks for waiting. What if I was jerking one off?”
He barked out a laugh before saying, “Yeah, you never do before a game. Helps keep you focused. Wasn’t that the bullshit you gave us last year?”
Oops—I forgot about my rule. “I play better pent-up. What did you need?”
“Right. My left shoulder has been giving me some trouble. I iced it with Nicole a couple of days but it’s still pinching. Do you have that muscle relaxer from your pulled muscle last year?”
“Ah, yeah. I think it’s in the bathroom.”
“Sweet. I’ll grab it.”
“I can—” I froze when his fingers closed around the handle. I had no idea if Kenzie was in her room or had clothes on or was standing there, listening. If we get caught…
“Get the fuck out, Aaron!” Her voice came from the behind the door and Aaron jumped back, mortified.
“Hurry up. I need to get something from under the sink.”
“I’m busy.”
“Are you taking a shit or what?”
“I will kill you, Aaron. I swear to god.”
Aaron laughed real hard and hit the doorframe before giving me his attention. “Can you grab it for me when she’s…done in there?”
“You got it.”
“I bet it’s entertaining sharing a bathroom with her.”
“You could say that.” I kept my face passive, hoping he didn’t suspect anything more than I was willing to share. Yeah, it was more than entertaining to have her in the room next to mine for the rest of the summer. It was torture, but yeah, I just nodded. Keep it cool. “I’m not bored.”
He snorted and moved to my door. “Thanks for being so chill about letting my little sis live here. I appreciate it.”
I’m the fucking worst. “Of course.”
“See you tomorrow. I gotta get back to Greta.” He walked into his room and left his door open.
It felt weird to shut mine, as though he was baiting me.
But that didn’t make sense. Aaron would punch me in the face if he knew, I was sure.
I waited five minutes before moving to the bathroom and grabbing the relaxer from under the sink.
I poked my head into Kenzie’s room, saw her with her goddamn list and winked at her.
She made an impatient face and crossed her arms. “I wasn’t taking a shit.”
“I know,” I replied, hoping I kept my smile from breaking through. “Nice cover, by the way.”
“Yeah, go give that stuff to my brother. I’m not done being embarrassed.”
“You’re so fucking cute.”
I didn’t mean to say it to her, but it came out and I had to own it. “Stay put, Kenzie. We still have to chat.”