Chapter 11
The New Enemy
Eli
The two girls next to me giggle. Again. The redhead keeps touching my thigh. I’m so done with this. It was the deal, but I’m over it. I’d rather take Harper back in the house and fuck her.
Ashley studies me. Does she have a new boyfriend too? Or just Sidney?
Fuck, I hope she does. The catty looks are getting old. Not that a boyfriend ever stopped her from coming to me.
Zach Gray drapes his arm over Sidney’s shoulders. He’s the same height as Luke, similar build. He plays basketball. He’s got sandy blond hair and brown eyes. From what Luke said, he fits the profile.
I glance over at Luke and Harper. They’re both tense, and Luke is eyeing Zach.
“I was on my way, Zach. I just wanted to apologize to Harper for making her smell like me.” Sidney’s tone is too nice. Fuck that bitch.
He grins. “You don’t need to apologize, babe. I love the way you smell.”
His gaze flicks up to Harper for a heartbeat before lifting to Luke. It’s subtle, but he’s letting her know he sees her. What’s his game?
“Is that the girl you guys claimed?” He doesn’t look at her again, but he’s aware of her. I want to move closer, protect her, but that’s not the right move here. I need to wait and see what he gives away.
“Yes.” Luke’s voice is calm, but I can hear the rage he’s holding back.
“Good luck with that one. I hear she’s a prude. But I feel like I should thank you for letting Sidney go. Stupid if you ask me, but hey, I get it, you guys like to break them in. Me? I just like to fuck.” His gaze finally drops to Harper. The smile he gives her is anything but nice and friendly.
I laugh, drawing his attention away from her so she can breathe. I want him to know that I see him. His purpose is to make my girl uncomfortable. Fuck that.
“What’s so funny, Eli?” Zach raises his eyebrow.
“You acting like you know our girl.” I stand and brush off my jeans.
Zach smiles like he’s caught a mouse with his bait. “I don’t have to know her to know her type. Too tense to relax. Won’t take a dick in the mouth unless you force it. The only way to fuck that pussy is to hold her thighs apart until she takes it.”
“Fuck, Zach. I think I can speak for all the girls here when I say maybe take the toxic masculinity to a lower level.” I move between him and Harper. “Why don’t you worry about your girl and stop thinking about ours.”
His eyes lock with mine, but he still has that cocky smile. He laughs like he didn’t just describe raping Harper. I don’t go for public beat downs, but Zach is pushing it. If he really was the one planning on raping Harper, he’ll find out what happens to assholes who need stopped.
What we did to Tanner will look like a fucking kindness.
“Eli, maybe you should take advantage of the lovely pussy before you.” He turns and faces Ashley. “You need to fuck that rage out of your system, my man.” He grabs my shoulder and squeezes. “Coming on a girl’s tits is only so satisfying.”
“Is that how you get off, Zach?” Jack steps up beside me. He glances at Sidney. “I mean she’s got decent tits, but almost everyone has come on Sidney’s tits. Mostly because she doesn’t like to swallow.”
“Fuck off, Jack.” Sidney shakes her head. “I swallow.”
Zach chuckles. Smirking, he looks Jack up and down. “Maybe you do have an outlet for fucking.”
“Yeah.” Ashley steps forward. “Is Jack taking one for the team? Or maybe all for the team?”
“Hey.” Emma’s brow scrunches as she glares at Ashley. “That’s not cool.”
I smile and knock Zach’s hand off my shoulder. “We’re all committed to fucking one girl.”
“Sounds boring.” Zach scoffs.
“So you two aren’t exclusive then?” I wait to see what Sidney does. It was the one thing she wanted from Luke. Exclusivity. She didn’t like him fucking around, but he didn’t give a shit what she wanted. She always came back for more. “Brewster’s dick wasn’t enough for you, Sidney?”
She laughs and drapes her arms around Zach. “I’ve found a real man.”
Her gaze hunts for Luke. Yeah, that bitch is still digging at that hole even though it leads to nowhere.
“How long do you think the little virgin will hold out?” Zach asks Sidney.
Sidney laughs. “Maybe the whole year.”
“For fuck’s sake.” Harper pushes between Jack and me and steps in front of us. “Not that it’s any of your business, but I’m not a virgin anymore.”
Jack wraps a hand around her hip and draws her back against him. “She’s ours.”
Sidney actually looks a little shocked. A storm moves across Zach’s face before it clears. Yeah, that fucker is the one. We need to make a plan how best to put him down.
“You work fast.” His gaze takes her in.
“Fuck, there’s no winning with you guys. First, I’m a whore, then I’m a prude, what next? A slut. Fuck off. I chose and I chose them.” Harper takes my hand in hers. She trembles, and I entwine our fingers.
It’s not how she wanted to put it out there, but it should be effective. By the end of tonight, everyone will know she’s no longer a virgin.
“Well, fuck, darling. I didn’t know you needed a whole team to make you surrender.” Zach’s grin is feral. The darling isn’t lost on me. Nor is Harper’s reaction to the word.
Her hand crushes mine. “Only assholes have to trap a girl to fuck her.”
With her brows furrowed, Sidney glances at Zach with a questioning look.
Zach laughs. “Let’s go, Sidney. I need a drink and your mouth tonight.”
Sidney remembers her surroundings. Her face clears before she sneers at Harper. “Tick tock, little whore.”
Ashley fixes a glare on me before she follows the others.
Harper wraps her hand around my arm. Her brown eyes plead with me. “I need a breather.”
We can’t all disappear right now. Not after that confrontation. I glance at Luke.
“Five minutes,” I mouth to him and he nods.
Jack murmurs something in Harper’s ear before he returns to the couch. I draw Harper to the door and put in the code. As soon as we’re through the door and it shuts behind us, she sags against me.
“That was him,” she whispers as she clutches my shirt.
Fuck, I’m not usually the guy girls go to for comfort. I lift her in my arms and take her into the office across the hall, flipping on the light switch. I lower both of us to the leather couch.
She trembles against me and buries her head in my neck. I’m not sure where to put my hands or what to do. The fucker trapped her in the closet and told her he was going to rape her. He all but admitted it in front of us.
I run my hand down her back. “You did well.”
She laughs bitterly. “My stomach churned the whole time. I’m surprised I didn’t vomit all over them.”
I tip her face up to mine. Her wide brown eyes search mine, but she’s not crying.
“You definitely fed the gossip mill.” I rub my thumb along her jaw.
Her smile is small. “Yeah, that didn’t go according to plan. I should have stopped drinking.”
“We can’t stay back here long.” I glance toward the party. Even in here, the bass thumps. “I’m sure your ruin will be spread everywhere by the time we get back.”
She chuckles and plays with the button on my shirt. “I’m surprised they thought I was still a virgin.”
“It’s not like piercing your ears. No one knows unless they see you taking dick or you spill about it.” I massage her hip.
She sighs and rests her head on my shoulder. “It would be so much easier just to seclude ourselves back here.”
“Honestly, it would, but we have to go out there. We have to be present and show them they didn’t win.” My time is almost up. We need to show them we’re still in control.
She lifts her head and cups my jaw. “Thank you.”
She leans in and touches her lips to mine. I take over the kiss, testing her to see if she can meet my needs. Her lips open for me. She lets me take and take. When I break off the kiss, she looks up at me a little dazed.
“We need to get back.”
Harper
Caden keeps the drinks coming as I settle on the couch between him and Luke. I talk a little with Penny, but the girls wander away as the night grows later. They find other friends or guys to talk to until it’s just my guys and me on the couch.
Kenz has disappeared, probably with Brandon.
Caden keeps teasing that spot under my knee. It’s intense and pleasurable, but it’s not enough to push me over. I’m so ready to move onto the next part of our night.
I catch glimpses of Zach through the dark mass of people before me. Every time I see him, he’s watching me. Shivers race through me, and I’m not sure confessing my lack of a hymen was useful.
He doesn’t seem less interested. The alcohol mutes the fear.
If anything, I notice a lot more girls looking at my guys. Yeah, that was bound to happen sooner or later. The name calling will probably escalate. I’m just glad I don’t have P.E. this year. I’d hate to be in that locker room ever again.
Luke draws me onto his lap, guiding me to straddle his hips. His hands slide over my ass under my skirt.
“How do you feel, princess?”
I cup his face and stare into his icy eyes. Fuck it. I kiss him.
I’m beyond caring what anyone thinks. He draws me in close and takes over the kiss. I barely realize when he lifts me against him, and the noise of the party fades into nothing but strong footsteps and darkness.
I’m lost in a haze. Luke’s kiss consumes me. Lights turn on and a door closes. He sets me on my feet and backs away. I sway a little. I’m definitely buzzed, but I want this.
I want them.
“Strip, kitten.” Eli steps up behind me. His words brush over the nape of my neck and desire pools hot and heavy in my core. They’re all around me, hungry, waiting, anticipating. My breath catches.
The jersey slips over my head, followed by my t-shirt. My skirt flutters to the ground. I’m aware of the five sets of hungry eyes on me. They move with me, discarding their clothes until we’re all down to our underwear.
Eli releases my bra and kisses my shoulder as he lowers it off me. Jack steps up and slides his hands into my panties on the sides before lowering them. I touch his solid, warm chest, discovering the curves and valleys of his hard muscles.
I could spend a day exploring each of their bodies and still not get enough.
Trailing my fingers lower to his waistband, I slide my hands beneath, grasping his hot flesh in my grip. My pussy pulses empty, needy. Caden closes in on my back with his heat and presence. I meet Jack’s mesmerizing blue eyes, and he lowers his mouth to mine.
Caden slides his lubed fingers around the plug and then pulls it out. I gasp into Jack’s mouth. When Caden moves away, Eli returns. He trails his hands over my curves as Jack kisses me.
“Are you ready, sweetheart?” Jack whispers against my lips.
Nodding, I push his boxers down. I’m so ready. Eli lifts me against him. I lean back into him, taking his warmth, feeling his skin slide against mine. I’m dizzy, but grounded.
When Eli lowers me down to the floor, our bodies glide against each other. My knees fall to either side of Caden’s head and he drags me down so his mouth can consume my pussy.
He’s amazing at eating me out. It’s ravenous and almost feral the way he fucks me with his mouth.
Hands press me down so my body lies against Caden’s. His cock is out of reach for my mouth, but I stroke my hands over it, loving the solid feel of his smooth cock. My eyes flutter shut as his tongue explores me, devours me.
Fingers press inside me. My pussy. My ass. Stroking in and out as Caden sucks on my clit.
My release comes over me in a wave, sweeping me under and holding me down as wave after wave of pleasure rips through my body. I moan in agony and delight and so many other emotions as I tighten my fingers around Caden’s cock.
Hands hold me, rub me, touch me, keying me up again. So many hands. I kiss Caden’s abs as his tongue works in and out of my pussy. The fingers withdraw from my puckered hole and Jack’s wet cock head takes their place, pressing against my asshole.
“Shh, princess, don’t tense. Just relax.” Luke’s voice makes me want to obey.
When Jack doesn’t press in, I relax as the hands work me up and Caden’s tongue pushes me closer and closer to another orgasm. I stroke his cock, wishing it was in my mouth.
Jack pushes his cock into my ass, slowly easing in.
“Ah.” I tremble beneath him. The pressure is similar to the plug, and I relax against it.
“Good girl, kitten.”
Jack sinks in deeper, and I cry out as Caden pushes me over the edge. Jack holds still. I can feel his cock inside my ass. I breathe through my climax. His fingers massage my ass cheeks as he waits patiently.
I press back, letting more of him slide inside me. Fuck, that feels good. I rock back and forth building friction while his cock slides within me. I press back, taking more and more of him until my hips run into his.
“How does that feel, little nympho?” Caden’s warm breath on my pussy almost pushes me over the edge again.
“Good.” I rock against Jack.
Jack takes my hips and draws his cock out until only the tip remains before easing back in.
“Oh, fuck,” I widen my legs and Caden’s tongue sweeps over my clit. “Ah.”
“Any pain, sweetheart?” Jack pulls out and thrusts back in.
“No,” I whimper, needing more. He picks up the pace, thrusting a little faster.
“Your ass is so fucking tight, Harper. It’s the best.” Jack sounds breathy as he pumps his cock into my ass.
Crying out, I clench around his cock, but he keeps working me through it, thrusting in deep before pulling out and doing it again. Caden slides his fingers into my pussy making me feel so fucking full that I fall over the edge again.
This time I pull Jack with me. He groans and thrusts in deep as his warm cum fills me. It triggers aftershocks, and I collapse on top of Caden’s body. Jack pulls out, and I think I feel him fall to the side of Caden.
Panting, I try to come down and catch my breath.
Fuck. I did it. I’m totally not a virgin anymore. Caden slides me down his body. His cock presses at my pussy entrance and slides inside. I put my hands on his thighs as he thrusts up into me.
“Oh, fuck, Caden.” My sensitive pussy trembles around his cock, ready to explode.
Eli kneels in front of me, stroking his cock. I meet his dark eyes and lower my mouth to kiss his cock. He grips my hair.
“Open, kitten.”
When I part my lips, his cock fills my mouth while Caden’s cock thrusts into my pussy. Caden parts my ass cheeks.
“Fuck, little nympho.” He slides his fingers into my ass and I come. “I can’t wait to fuck your ass with my cock.”
Eli fucks my mouth while Caden grinds up into my pussy. The others are near. When these two finish with me, I’ll gladly take the others. They’re mine and I’m all theirs.