Chapter 12
The Truce
Caden
The alcohol makes Harper loose and relaxed, but her pussy is tight and her ass squeezes tighter around my fingers. When she comes again, she drags me into my release. Groaning, I pull her hips down on me and buck into her as my cum spills deep inside her.
I never cared about coming into a condom. It was necessary. But feeling Harper’s tight heat soaking my cock as it pulses around me is an experience I want over and over again. She moans and clutches at me as Eli groans his release into her mouth.
Pulling my fingers out of her ass, I sit up with my cock still hard inside her. Her back presses against my chest as she relaxes into me.
“Still feeling buzzed, little nympho?” I cup her breast and toy with her nipple, feeling her pussy pulse around me. Such a needy little cunt she has.
She gasps. “Yes, Caden.”
I’ve noticed she calls me War when she wants to taunt me or push me. Right now, she’s just mine and I’m hers. We haven’t settled the gap between us, but she told me everything that happened to her tonight.
It’s a start. She’s trusting me, or doesn’t want punishment, or maybe she doesn’t give a fuck about me anymore, but at least she’s opening up to me.
I have plans to fix the other guy that’s irritating me, but Zach will be harder to eliminate. He’s got his own popularity and following. Sherman High is a large enough school our sports teams don’t cross pollinate often. Yes, we’re the top dogs, but each social tier has their own leaders.
We’ve been cordial to Zach Gray, and he’s been the same to us, but he’s drawn first blood.
He went after Harper. We can’t stand for that.
Luke holds his hands down to Harper, and she takes them, lifting off my cock. I could stay inside her all night. Fuck, I might try that. Now that she’s all ours there are no more limits.
I step into the bathroom and wash up a little. Nothing is put on hold while I’m out of the room though. With five guys at her beck and call, my girl still gets her pleasure.
The sounds she makes is like music to my ears. Her soft pants, loud moans, needy noises. Fuck, my cock is already hard again, eager for another round.
When I walk out, Luke has her spread out on the bed. His fingers glisten as he works them in and out of her pussy. Nico kisses her mouth like a man on a mission.
He fucked up. We still haven’t talked about it. But being on the outs with our girl sucks. I’m still there.
Tonight is a tentative ceasefire, but she’s still mad at me. I’m softening in my anger toward her. She’s been more open about what’s happening to her, which is good, but I still see red when I think of Tanner having any access to her.
Eli lifts his mouth off Harper’s breast and I see the redness of her nipple and the imprints of his teeth. There are faint red marks on her soft pale skin that will turn into hickeys tomorrow. Fucker likes to mark her up.
Nico’s kiss muffles Harper’s cry as she comes, arching against those three. I stand next to Jack and stroke myself as Luke lubes up his cock.
“Easy, Luke.” I don’t want him to ruin this experience for her by making it hurt.
He glances at me and nods. I’m not surprised he wants her ass. If the guy had his way, he would have taken every first and kept Harper as his. Fuck, I might have too.
My little nympho may have been untouched, but she’s eager and willing, after some coercion on our part. She picked me and Jack for her firsts. I still can’t believe she chose me to be her first.
Luke presses her knees up against her chest as Nico draws away from her mouth and Eli steps back. Her blown brown eyes meet his as he eases his cock into her recently devirginized ass. Her lips part, and she moans as she takes every inch of him into her.
Fuck, my cock twitches. I’m not going there. She’s not ready to take my cock in her ass yet even if she can handle Luke’s. But I’ll get her there.
“You think she’s ready for both?” Jack strokes his cock as we both watch Luke fuck her ass. He goes slow and easy on her as she pants and moans. Their eye contact is intense even to me.
Can she take me in her pussy and Jack in her ass?
“She’ll take it.” My balls tighten thinking of how tight she’ll be with him inside her. Just the way she tightened around my fingers in her pussy when he was in her ass was so fucking tight and perfect. With her squeezing tight around my cock, I only hope I can last to make it good for her.
She cries out as she comes. Luke groans as he unloads into her ass. They stay like that for a moment. Their eyes locked. She makes him feel, which is a feat in itself. Hell, she makes me feel too. She belongs to us.
All of her.
He draws out of her and she releases a sigh. Nico has a wet washcloth ready. Luke takes it and cleans her. She’s the only girl I’ve ever seen him be gentle with.
When he moves away, I step to the end of the bed.
“You want more, little nympho?”
She meets my eyes and parts her legs for me in invitation. Fuck, she’s under my skin.
I crawl over her and drop my forehead to hers. “I’m not taking that ass, little nympho. We’ll work up to you taking me there, but tonight, you can take both me and Jack. Is that what you want? Me in your tight cunt while Jack fucks your ass?”
She licks her lips and glances at Jack before nodding. Her fingers trace my lips. “Yes, please.”
“Do you feel any pain?” I ask because if so, we’re done with the ass play for the night.
She sinks her fingers into my hair. “No, Caden. It doesn’t hurt.”
I kiss her like I might never get the chance again. Fuck, she’s like a drug and I can’t get enough of her.
Harper
My whole body is on fire. Each of these guys strikes a match and sets me ablaze. Luke in my ass was amazing. He took me slowly, gently. I know it won’t always be that way with him, but fuck, it made something in my heart pulse a little harder as his cool eyes held mine.
Caden’s lips move from mine, kissing down my neck to my breast. Not the one that still stings from Eli’s teeth. Caden sucks my breast into his mouth like he’s starved. Pulses of desire course through me to settle between my legs as he draws on my nipple.
I’m not tipsy enough to not be aware, but the alcohol definitely relaxes me, as does their constant attention. I dig my fingers into Caden’s hair, holding him to my breast. His tongue sweeps around my nipple as he draws on me, pulling at something low and deep inside me.
I tug him up, needing to feel his hot mouth on mine. As his tongue slips into my mouth, his cock thrusts into my pussy. When I gasp, he chuckles into my mouth before rolling onto his back with me on top of him.
He holds me to him, devouring my mouth as his hips thrust his cock deep inside me, winding me tight, making me need more. Caden holds my hips still for a moment while Jack spreads my ass cheeks open and applies more lube over my asshole.
“Pain?” His voice is soft.
“No pain,” I say as I kiss Caden’s jaw and Caden dips to claim my mouth again.
Jack eases his tip inside, rubbing against the sensitive nerves before he presses deeper. I groan into Caden’s mouth.
It’s so much tighter with Caden inside me too and being squeezed between the two of them. I can feel them against the thin walls of my insides, pressing against each other.
“Fuck,” Luke murmurs. “She’s taking you both beautifully.”
My pussy pulses at Luke’s praise. I rest my head on Caden’s chest and focus on breathing as they begin to move gently. Jack pulls out while Caden thrusts in. When Jack thrusts in, Caden pulls out. Their warm bodies surround me, cocooning me.
I shiver between them as sparks ride my nerves, making me feel so high. The pressure wells within me. The sensation of them moving against each other within overwhelms me until I’m just this throbbing mass between them.
When my orgasm rips through me, I cry out at the intensity. They both keep moving inside me until Jack buries his cock deep and his warm cum fills my ass. His cock jerks and pulses as he comes.
Caden bucks up into me and groans, coming deep inside me. I can feel every tremor, every pulse of his cock as his warm cum fills my pussy, pushing me into another release. Jack withdraws and falls on the bed beside me while I lay limp on Caden as his cock softens within me.
All of us breathe heavily. Caden strokes my ass while his chest rises and falls under me. Jack runs his hand down my side as his blue eyes hold mine. His smile makes my insides glow.
“Worth the wait, sweetheart.”
My cheek rests against Caden’s chest. I’m not sure how much more I have in me for tonight. But I know I have one more guy to go at least. Nico hasn’t come yet. But I’m just going to rest my eyes for a second.
I wake up to Caden carrying me into the bathroom. Someone already ran a bath and Eli rests in it, waiting for me. Caden lowers me, and Eli situates me between his legs. My back rests against his chest.
Caden walks into the shower.
The warm water helps relax my muscles. Eli drags a warm washcloth over my skin, rubbing at every inch of me. My hair is still up in the ponytail. It’s a little looser now. Sighing, I rest my head against his chest.
“You okay, kitten?” He runs the washcloth over my breasts.
“Yes.” I release my breath. I feel a little weird right now. Not because of his gentle touch, but because I’ve just had sex with multiple guys like it’s not a big deal. Like this is what they trained me to become.
Mostly I want to do it again, but not right away. Right now, I’m sleepy.
Eli slides his fingers down between my legs. I suck in a breath, waiting for him to push me into another orgasm, but he just gently cleans me.
“Relax, kitten. We know you’ve done a lot tonight.” Eli’s fingers trail drops of water down my neck. “We’re just going to clean you up and go to sleep. Okay?”
“Okay.” I slide my hands over his knees. “What are we going to do about Zach Gray?”
They promised to protect me. But everyone who’s come after me so far never would have noticed me if the horsemen hadn’t claimed me.
“We’ll discuss it later. We’re all tired and drained. It’s been a long day.” Eli brushes the back of his fingers along my breast and up my neck. Shivers race through me.
It has been a long day. After a few more minutes of soaking, Nico holds a towel out for me. Eli helps me stand and I step into Nico’s arms. I lift my eyes to his.
“You haven’t come.”
He gives me a soft smile as he runs the towel over my body. “I’m good, sunshine. We have all weekend.”
Caden comes in wearing only his boxers and lowers one of his t-shirts over my head.
“You sore, little nympho?” He cups my jaw as Nico walks back into the bedroom.
Shaking my head, I meet his green eyes. I even double check. The bath seems to have helped with any sore muscles. The only things that hurt are my arms from holding the door shut earlier.
When he lifts me into his arms, I let out a startled noise and wrap my arms around his neck. His grin is decidedly wicked as he carries me into his bedroom. The others are on the bed in their boxers.
Caden kisses me before lowering me to my feet. I crawl onto the bed between Eli and Nico. If I could, I’d have them all surround me, but I haven’t gotten to spend the night with these two in a while.
“How do you feel about someone touching you while you’re asleep, sunshine?” Nico runs his hand along the hem of Caden’s shirt on my thighs.
I resist the urge to part my thighs for him. Just the thought of them playing with me while I sleep makes me wet. “I’m willing to try it.”
Nico kisses me. “Good girl.”
A shiver courses through me as I settle into the warmth of these two men.