Chapter 36
Jesse
She’d never been so humiliated and so turned on at the same time in her entire life. It felt as though she might actually be consumed by the flames of both at any moment as Daddy sat on the bed and pulled her over his lap.
Then Daddy’s hands were on her ass, pulling her cheeks apart, leaving her more exposed and vulnerable than she’d ever been. The pain from her switching only added more fuel to that humiliation-slash-arousal fire, and she whimpered as she buried her face in her arms to try and hide from all of it.
“Relax your bottom, baby.” Daddy’s gruff tone told her he was just as affected by all of this as she was, though probably without the added dash of humiliation. That was solely for her, their naughty babygirl.
Which was a role she was more than happy to play.
She focused on forcing her muscles to loosen, though she did instinctively clench a bit when the cold lube hit her exposed bottom hole. Not that she could even really clench all that much with Daddy’s large hands spreading her so open.
“Such a pretty little hole, just waiting to be filled.” As if to demonstrate her point, Edie pressed a finger against Jesse’s slick hole, pushing against what little resistance she had left in her.
“It’s not!” Jesse cried, shaking her head in a protest she already knew would go unheeded. “It’s not waiting to be filled! It’s perfectly happy being not filled!”
She was caught in some odd place between Little and Big. While her body’s reactions were very much Big Girl reactions, it was a struggle not to slip into her Little space a bit when they were talking to her like a naughty Little girl. It was just enough to add an element of the taboo to what was already a ‘forbidden’ and humiliating act, and by the time Edie’s finger was completely buried in her bottom, Jesse was nearly consumed with the aching need to be claimed by both of them.
“Mommy,” she whined, pressing her hips into Daddy’s thigh to try and alleviate at least some of the torment. “Mommy, please.”
“Please, what, babygirl?” Chuckling softly, Edie slowly fucked her bottom with her finger. “Please stretch out this naughty little hole for Daddy’s cock? I’d be happy to.”
“No!” Jesse wailed, her head thrashing side to side. “Not that!”
But as she’d expected, her protests went completely ignored. Edie pulled her finger free, but only to add a second one along with the first, stretching her tight hole and driving her even more out of her mind with need.
“How does that feel, little outlaw? Do you like the way Mommy stretches your pretty bottom hole?”
“No! No, I don’t like it at all, Daddy!”
“Hmm. Maybe Mommy should check to see if you’re telling us the truth.”
She had no doubt Edie could see exactly what kind of effect their play was having on her. And still, she tried her best to close her legs in the hope she might get away with it.
No such luck. Edie’s other hand slipped between her thighs and a moment later a soft tsking sound reached Jesse’s ears.
“I don’t think she was being very truthful, Daddy. Look at this.”
Though Jesse couldn’t actually see what was happening, she could feel Edie’s hand leaving her pussy, and she could hear Daddy’s exaggerated sigh of disapproval.
“Naughty little outlaw. You keep this up and you’re going to be waiting a very long time to come tonight.”
Horror filled her at his threat. “I’m sorry, I’m sorry! I’ll be good, I promise!”
“Edie, I think she’s ready for our first surprise.”
“Wait!” Now it was panic clawing at her, fueling the fire of her arousal. “What surprise? What’s happening?”
“Just a little something to get you ready for Daddy’s cock in your bottom. Can you be a big girl and take it for us?”
It didn’t take her long to find out what the ‘little something’ was. And it wasn’t little at all. Thick, hard rubber replaced Edie’s fingers, stretching her with even more of a pinch and burn than before.
“Such a good girl,” Edie praised softly, working the fake cock in and out of her bottom with torturously slow movements. “Daddy, I think our babygirl deserves a reward for taking our surprise so well.”
“I think so, too.” Releasing his hold on her bottom, he slid a hand down to where she burned for them. “Are you going to show us how pretty you are when you come, baby?”
“Y-yes, Daddy!” she cried as he pressed a finger to her clit. As close as she was, it wasn’t going to take much to set her off. Need coiled in her belly as he swirled a fingertip around the oversensitive little nub.
Sensation overwhelmed her. Pain and pleasure lost all meaning as they melded into one with every stroke of the cock in her sore bottom and every stroke of her Daddy’s finger over her clit.
“Show us.” Edie pressed the rubber cock in as deep as it would go, and Jesse’s pussy clenched as if in jealousy. “Come for us, babygirl.”
Pleasure exploded within her, shattering her as she bucked and writhed over her Daddy’s lap. And all the while, Edie continued fucking her bottom as Daddy drained every last ounce of pleasure from her body, until she finally collapsed, completely spent and unable to move.
“Beautiful,” Daddy murmured, patting her bottom gently. “I can’t wait to watch you do it again, with both your little holes full of us.”
Oh, god. What had she gotten herself into?
Grant
Jesse’s quiet whimper had his cock jumping in response. There was nothing like those sounds his girls made to get him hard as a fucking rock.
Though watching Edie fuck their babygirl’s bottom with a dildo certainly hadn’t helped matters. As he’d watched Jesse’s tight little hole open for the fake cock, the ring of muscle turning nearly white as it stretched to accommodate the rubber, all he could think about was how badly he wanted it to be his own cock stretching her, filling her.
And now it was finally his turn.
“Why don’t you go get yourself ready, little pixie, and I’ll finish getting our girl ready for our second surprise.”
Excitement lighting her eyes, Edie scrambled off the bed and stripped. Grant slowly pulled the dildo from Jesse’s limp form and set it off to the side.
“Come on, babygirl. Let’s get you out of these clothes.”
She whined some more as he stripped her naked. Probably because he took every opportunity he could to touch her, and after the orgasm she’d just had she was likely feeling very sensitive all over.
Especially her pretty little nipples, which called to him as he tossed her bra to the side. Cupping her breasts in his hands, he pinched the soft buds between his fingers, hard enough to have her arching up into his touch with a cry.
“Daddy, no!”
“Poor baby. Does that hurt?”
“Yes,” she answered with a pitiful little sniffle. “Lots.”
“Well, maybe if you ask nicely, Mommy will kiss them and make them feel better.”
Mommy. The word still felt odd on his tongue, but he was getting used to it. There was a connection there, between Mommy and Daddy, stronger than what he’d felt with Edie before. Whether it was the word itself or the fact she’d finally agreed to be theirs forever, he wasn’t sure. But he could feel it, like a physical bond between them, growing stronger with every passing second.
“I’d like that very much.” Edie’s voice was deeper than usual, rough with unslaked need as she knelt on the other side of the bed. A thick cock, larger and even more lifelike than the one they’d used earlier, jutted out from her mound. It was attached to the harness wrapped around her upper thighs, and she’d been practicing with it in secret for almost a week for this very purpose.
Turning her head, Jesse gasped at the sight. “What’s going on?”
“I told you, babygirl.” A wicked grin curved Edie’s lips. “Daddy and I are going to fill both your sweet little holes. You’re going to take him in your bottom, while you take me in your pussy. How’s that sound?”
“Um. It sounds like I’m not sure how the hell both of you are supposed to fit inside me.”
“You let us worry about that,” Grant said, giving her nipples another hard pinch. “Your body was made for us. Made for this. We’ll fit. You just have to be a good girl and take everything we give you. Can you do that for us, baby?”
“I’ll try, Daddy.”
“Good girl. Lay down on your side, facing Mommy.”
When he released her, she rolled onto her side as instructed, one leg slung over Edie’s hip as Edie worked the thick cock into her pussy. Thanks to the orgasm they’d given her, she didn’t seem to struggle to take it all the way inside her.
He watched, fascinated and so filled with love he thought he might burst as they moved together, each getting used to the unfamiliar angles and movements.
His babygirl. His pixie. His women. It was still somewhat shocking to him that he not only got to love one but both of these incredible women, and he promised himself then and there he would do whatever it took to keep their little family together.
And then Edie looked up with him, and he saw his own raw emotion reflected in the dark depths of her eyes. “Are you going to join us, Daddy?”
Taking his spot behind Jesse, he gripped his painfully hard cock in his hand and guided it toward her bottom hole. “Hold her still for me, pixie.”
“Yes, Daddy.”
Jesse opened for him beautifully, her bottom stretching around him more easily than usual, yet still clamping down around him as he pushed his cock into her. She whined between them, burying her face in Edie’s shoulder.
“It hurts,” she whined.
“I know, baby. But Daddy will make it feel better in a minute. You’re being such a good girl for us.”
“That’s right, little outlaw.” Flexing his hips, he drove forward a bit more, burying himself in her bottom as he leaned down to press a kiss to her shoulder. “And you feel so fucking good on Daddy’s cock. Do you like having both of us inside you?”
A shudder wracked her body. “Y-yes, Daddy.”
“Good girl. We’re going to fuck you now, and you’re going to take us, but if you need us to stop, what are your words?”
“Yellow to slow, Red to stop.” Tilting her head back, she smiled up at him. “I won’t need my words, Daddy. I trust you. Both of you.”
“I love you, little outlaw.”
“I love you, too, Daddy.” Her gaze shifted to the dark-haired beauty in front of them. “I love you, Edie.”
“I love you both. So fucking much,” Edie said with a groan as she moved her hips. When they’d originally talked about this plan for their babygirl, he’d had his doubts that it would be as enjoyable for Edie as it would for him and Jesse. But judging by her gasps and moans, the cock she wore was hitting just the right spot as she moved with him inside their babygirl.
There was nothing left to say after that. Soon the room filled with the sound of their bodies moving together, of their gasps and moans and whimpers as three became one.
And then of his girls’ cries of pleasure as they both crested the wave together, wrapped up in each other. He followed soon after, filling his babygirl’s bottom one final time as she spasmed around him.
Later, when they’d showered and cleaned themselves up, they lay in a heap on the too-small bed, both of his girls asleep on top of him, and he wondered how the hell he’d gotten so lucky.