Chapter 35
The Lit Fuse
Luke
Caden stands and heads for the bathroom. I follow him. My mind still can’t wrap around what happened. She chose Caden to be her first. Not me.
Does she only want Caden, and she’s tolerating the rest of us?
Fuck that.
Caden knocks on the bathroom door. “You okay?”
Harper opens the door with her cheeks stained pink. She nods and looks at me. Her dark eyes flash with heat. My body responds with a primal need to claim her, but I hold myself back.
“What do you need?” Caden cups her cheek, tipping her head to meet his eyes. “It’s up to you how we go from here.”
Her eyes widen, and her gaze darts back to me. Her face softens when she turns back to Caden and puts her hand over his. “I’m good. We can explore more or do something else.”
“Why don’t we put on a movie and relax for a little while?” Nico suggests.
My jaw clenches, but I can see their point. Just because I want to fuck her, doesn’t mean they don’t want to fuck her too. But she might be sore. Caden is a huge motherfucker.
I grab my boxers and my t-shirt. Before anyone else can, I step forward and put my t-shirt on over her head and help her get her arms through. Needing to claim her in whatever way I can.
“Thank you.” She looks up at me shyly and brushes her hair behind her ear. This uncertain, shy thing she’s got going is new. I’m not sure I like it.
The others go to find their boxers, and I step into mine. She bites her lip as I put away my hard cock. Stepping into her, I feel her warmth against me and draw her into my arms. She wraps her arms around my waist and rests her head over my heart.
Can she tell how hard it pounds for her?
“We’ll go as slow as you want, princess.” I press my lips to the top of her dark hair, even as I want to rip out my own vocal cords. Every time I imagined Harper losing her virginity, I was the one taking it.
Now, Caden’s cum is the first our girl has tasted and had in her tight little cunt. Sure, I took her first orgasm, the first taste of her pussy, and the first to sleep with her, but fuck, I wanted them all.
Harper squeezes me tight and looks up at me. The others have moved to the TV and are scrolling to find something. Her dark eyes fascinate me.
“I don’t know how to do this,” she whispers. Her eyes search mine.
“Do what?” I glance over at the guys, who focus on the TV. Well, mostly focus. They glance over at Harper.
She swallows and drops her gaze to my throat. “I don’t want to be done.”
My cock throbs at what I hope she’s saying. I tip her chin to force her eyes to meet mine. “You want to play more, princess?”
Her tongue darts out to wet her lips. She nods.
The opening credits of a movie play in the background.
I can’t stop the smile that forms on my lips as I take her hand and lead her to a chair. I sit down and draw her down onto my lap, straddling me.
Sliding my hand between her legs, I stroke her pussy gently. She makes this little needy noise that makes my balls tighten and ache with need. Eli glances over at us from his chair and lifts an eyebrow at me.
I part her pussy lips and slip a finger inside her wet cunt, watching her eyes closely. “Sore?”
Her eyes lock on mine as she shakes her head. Her hips roll against my hand and finger.
I draw her down so I can speak in her ear. “Do you want to be passed around, princess?”
Her pussy clamps around my finger. “Yes.”
I grin. “You want my cock inside you? Do you want me to fuck you?”
Her fingers dig into my shoulders. “Yes, please, Luke.”
She lifts her head and meets my eyes as her fingers trail down my bare chest. My muscles twitch beneath her. I thrust my finger deeper into her before slowly sinking it in and out.
Her breathing gets rough, and her dark eyes seem endless as she reaches for the waistband of my boxers and lowers them, drawing out my cock. Her hand strokes me, and I bite back a curse.
“I need to feel you inside me,” she whispers. My cock twitches in her hand.
Drawing my finger out, I tease her clit. Her lips part and she gasps.
“I thought about this last night.” Her words are barely loud enough for me to hear, but they make my insides burn.
She lifts her hips and rubs the head of my cock against her pussy before positioning it at her entrance.
Our eyes lock and my breath catches. “How easy it would be to just guide you and take you.”
She lowers her pussy down over my cock. Slowly taking me all the way inside her. Her wet cunt surrounding my cock.
“Fuck.” I rest my forehead against hers as I fill her completely. She blows her breath out. I grab her hair and crash our lips together. Tentatively she rolls her hips against mine, and I almost lose it.
Never have I felt something as intense as this. Her movements are shy and unsure, but I don’t take over, letting her find her way because being inside her is enough. Knowing she trusts me enough to let me inside is enough.
I thrust my tongue into her mouth as she rides me.
Tasting every inch of her mouth, rediscovering her.
She’s slick and wet, and I never want this to end, but I want her to come on my cock.
My free hand slides up under my t-shirt to palm her breast. So soft and supple.
She groans into my mouth, pressing down harder, grinding her clit against me.
Reaching between us, I release her mouth and hold her. “Open your eyes, princess.”
She opens her darkened eyes. For a second, it’s just me and her and this chemical reaction between us that feels on the verge of exploding. Her hands slide around the back of my neck and dig into my hair.
“Luke. Ah, fuck.” Her lips part as she moves faster.
It takes all my strength to not thrust up into her, to let her find her pleasure.
I slide my finger against her clit. She tips her head back as she falls apart around me. Her pussy convulses, drawing me deeper. It’s so fucking intense, and I’m so fucking close. I thrust up into her. Her eyes come back to me. Her hands dig into my hair as I work her faster and harder.
I thrust deep inside her. Her eyes widen as she shatters around me again with a throaty moan, dragging me into my release. Groaning, I come inside her. Collapsing on top of me, she wraps her arms around my neck and buries her face into my shoulder.
Catching my breath, I rub my hand down her back. My gaze lifts and meets Caden’s. He smirks and arches a brow. I almost flick him off, but she’s in my arms. Fuck, this girl makes me feel something. I inhale her vanilla scent with the musk of our sex, loving the way she’s still wrapped around me.
I don’t want to let her go. I want to stay in this moment as long as I can. This moment of perfection. I also want to keep fucking her all day and into the night.
“Thank you, Luke,” she whispers in my ear. Her breath caressing it and making a shiver flow through me.
She lifts her head, and we look into each other’s eyes. In this moment, I would burn the whole world down for her if she asked. That kind of power over me should make me want to fight. But that’s part of the wonder of Harper, she wouldn’t ask that of me.
“Should I…?” She gestures to the bathroom.
“Come over here and give a repeat performance?” Jack says, drawing our attention. His hand strokes his cock as he raises an eyebrow. “I mean, when you’re ready, sweetheart. I don’t care if you’re overflowing with cum. As long as I get to add to it.”
Her dark eyes return to mine, and she kisses me, pressing her hips down over me, and her pussy flutters all around my cock. When she tries to pull away from the kiss, I grab her hair and wait for her eyes to meet mine.
“Next time, I’m fucking you, princess.”
She shivers against me, and I capture her lips, taking everything I can from her. My cock is still hard inside her, and I thrust up into her sweet fucking pussy. She gasps against my lips and grinds down on me.
I’m never going to get enough of this girl. I tear her mouth away from mine. She’s not just mine, as much as I want her to be. I smack her ass, and she tightens around me again.
“Go help Jack, princess.”
Her fingers trail over my jaw before she rises from me and makes her way over to Jack. My chest fills, knowing she’s wearing my shirt and filled with my cum. It’s enough for now.
Jack
Watching Harper get fucked is a whole new stage of arousal. I’m always game to watch each of us play with her, but watching Caden fill her with his cock was some next-level shit I’m going to need to see a lot of.
And her and Luke. I could sell tickets to that and make a mint if I wanted to share her with more than this group, which I don’t. I’m not sure Luke would let me, because that possessive look on his face… It was enough to almost make me cum.
She walks over to me almost shyly. This girl took all of our cocks in her mouth, and now she’s got a shy bone in her body. I’ll have to fuck that right out of her.
I stand as she reaches me. Her eyes lift to mine. I drop my boxers and take off her shirt, leaving us both naked. The TV plays in the background, but I’m sure no one is actually watching it right now.
She steps into the space dividing us. “Jack.”
I cup her cheek and lean down to claim her lips. She meets me like she always does. Our tongues collide, and she presses against me. Her hands rest on my chest.
When she’s nearly breathless, I lift my mouth. “Are you feeling sore, sweetheart?”
She meets my eyes and shakes her head.
“Want to try something different?”
Her eyes widen as her cheeks flush with heat. “What do you have in mind?”
I bend down so my lips are against her ear. My fingers go between her thighs and shove inside her, gathering the cum leaking out and shoving it in deeper. She gasps in my ear.
“You suck Caden’s cock while I fuck your pussy from behind.”
Her cunt squeezes around my fingers, and she releases a breath in my ear.
I grin. “You like the thought of that?”
When I lean back to see her answer, she nods. I draw my fingers out of her and bring them to my lips before taking them in. Her eyes widen. Cum doesn’t bother me. I enjoy going down on guys, so I’m not sure why she’s surprised.
I draw them out with a pop. “Did you want some?”
I slide them back inside her, and she grabs my arm. Her eyes darken as I fuck her with my fingers. When I pull them out, I hold my fingers in front of her lips. She takes them into her mouth, sucking and licking off the combination of her, Luke, and Caden. A heady mixture.
“Good, right?” I draw my fingers out and capture her mouth with mine. Tasting her. She moans into my mouth. This girl is everything I hoped she’d be. My cock twitches between us.
I shift us as I kiss her, until we’re in front of Caden. I lift my mouth from hers and turn her in my arms, holding her tight against my body, my cock resting against her ass. Nico sucks in a breath as he looks at her.
“Caden, be a good guy and get out your cock for your little nympho.” I slide one hand up to cup Harper’s breast and my other hand down to tease her clit. She squirms against me, making those needy little noises from earlier that almost made me come.
Caden draws his cock out of his shorts and strokes it.
“Damn, girl. That was inside you.” I lick my lips. “Even I haven’t taken anything that big. Yet.”
“Do you prefer guys?” she asks. I squeeze her nipple and rub her clit.
“My only preference is still breathing, sweetheart.” I kiss her jaw. “Trust me, I want to fuck you so badly. On your knees.”
We lower together in front of Caden, my hands still caressing her body.
“Take him in your mouth, and I’ll fuck your sweet pussy.” I dip my fingers inside her, and she gasps and widens her stance. Removing my hands, I press her to bend over Caden’s cock.
She glances up at Caden. With a smirk, he tucks his hands behind his head.
“This is your show, little nympho.”
She takes hold of his cock and pumps a few times before she opens her mouth and takes him inside. I rub the head of my cock against her slit. From the front all the way to her entrance and back forward.
She moans around Caden’s cock. Fuck, this girl was untouched two weeks ago, and now she wants all of us to fuck her. I wanted her from that first day, but I didn’t think we’d get here. Not really.
She takes his cock deeper, and I breach her entrance, pushing into her slick cunt easily. It’s tight all around me as I bury my cock into her. Wet and tight and everything I imagined it would be. She moans around Caden’s cock and presses back into me.
I grab her hips and spread her ass cheeks, staring at her little puckered hole as I pull out and thrust back into her. I pull out completely and shove my fingers inside to get them nice and wet, fucking her cunt with them a few times until she’s pushing back on me.
Drawing out my fingers, I thrust my cock deep into her pussy, and she pulls off Caden’s cock to groan. I slide my wet fingers around her asshole while I thrust into her pussy over and over again.
When she takes Caden into her mouth, I slip my finger into her asshole as I thrust forward. She cries out as she comes all over my cock.
“Suck his tip while I fuck you good, sweetheart.”
She backs off to just sucking Caden’s head in her mouth. I thrust deep and slide my finger deeper into her asshole. I add a second finger into her tight ass before I fuck her sweet pussy, holding my fingers deep inside her.
She makes the sweetest noises as I fuck her and she sucks on Caden’s cock. Her pussy tightens around me again as she comes, drawing me into my release. I slam into her as my cum fills her pussy. I fuck her ass with my fingers and feel her tighten again.
Caden groans his release as he fills her mouth with his cum. She swallows and convulses around me. Breathing heavily, she rests her head on Caden’s thigh. With gentle hands, he brushes her hair out of her face.
I ease out of her, and she sighs. Using my other hand, I push the cum back up inside her, sliding my finger in and out of her until she stiffens with an aftershock. I kiss her shoulder.
“You feel as good as I imagined you would, sweetheart.”
She snuggles back against me. “You too.”