Chapter 36
The Overwatch
Eli
The few times Jack and I took a girl together were hot, but nothing like watching my friends fuck Harper. She lifts her head from Caden’s lap, and our eyes meet. Fuck, this girl is dangerous. Even though she’s been thoroughly fucked, she looks like she needs more.
Like she wants more. I’m almost glad I wasn’t the one to take her virginity. I’m not sure I can control how I want to take her. I definitely wouldn’t have told her we could wait.
She stands and walks over to me, completely naked and completely fucked. I wait until she stops before me.
“Kneel, kitten.”
She drops to her knees and looks up. I take her chin in my hand.
“I’m not used to being gentle with girls.” I smooth my thumb over her lower lip. “If you want to wait, we can, but you need to remember your safe word if we’re going to fuck.”
Her eyes darken, and her tongue darts out to trace my thumb. “Arrow. I don’t want to stop.”
I lift my gaze to Luke. “I need assistance with my kitten.”
Luke stands with his boxers once again in place. He comes up behind Harper, drops to kneel behind her, and kisses her shoulder. Her eyes flutter shut, and a shudder works all the way down her body. So fucking responsive.
His hands grab her hips, but his eyes meet mine. Waiting to do whatever I say.
Focusing on Harper, I lean back. “I want you spread out before me. Luke will hold your hands down, and you’ll be mine to play with until I relinquish control of you. Do you want that, kitten?”
She swallows and nods. “Yes, Eli.”
“We’ll play other games later, but for now, I just want to fuck you.”
Her dark eyes never stray from mine as I stand and lower my boxers to the ground. While not as big as Caden, I’m large enough to be careful with my cock. But I can’t wait to tie Harper to the chair again, when nothing is off limits.
Dropping to my knees, I capture her lips with mine, palming her breast and pinching her nipple. She gasps into my mouth as I take from her. My cock brushes her stomach, and her nipples rub against my chest. I’m determined to last, but she tries my patience.
She reaches for my shoulders, but Luke takes her hands and holds them behind her. Sliding my hand down her belly, I lift my mouth from hers and watch her face.
“Open your eyes, kitten.”
She meets my eyes as I slip my hand between her thighs. I slide three fingers inside her. She moans, but I don’t see a flinch of pain. Good. I thrust them deep a few times, making sure, because I want to ride our girl hard. But I don’t want to hurt her. A little pain later won’t be an issue.
But the guys will throttle me if I hurt her while she’s getting used to us. I’ll be curious how far I can push her once I’m able to play with her on my own. But right now, she’s soaking wet with her slick and their cum, which should make this easier on her.
I grip her chin with my other hand and thrust my fingers in deep. “You don’t come until I tell you to, kitten. Or you’ll be punished.”
“Yes, Eli.” Her lips part, and her pupils are dilated. Her cunt flutters around my fingers. It won’t take much to get her to come. My cock twitches at the thought of punishing her.
Speaking to Luke, I say, “Lay her down. I want her arms stretched out over her head.”
Nodding, he whispers something in her ear before helping her down. I position her legs with her knees bent and out to the sides, opening up her pussy for me. She’s wet, pink, and a little swollen.
I slide two fingers back inside her. Her cunt clutches at my fingers as she holds my gaze. I curl my fingers inside her in a come here motion and brush her front wall, pressing on the spot that should make her come.
“Fuck,” she hisses as she tries to curl into herself.
I apply pressure, and she closes her eyes. Raising her hips, I slide a pillow beneath them before bending down to suck on her clit.
She squirms. Her breathing comes out in quick bursts. “Eli?”
I pull away. “Yes, kitten?”
Her dazed eyes meet mine. “If you keep that up, I’m going to come.”
“That’s the point, kitten.” I spread her thighs and lick her clit before latching on again. I press harder on her G-spot.
“Oh, fuck,” she cries out before she gushes all around me.
“That’s my girl.” I lift up and thrust my cock deep into her cunt with one stroke.
“Fuck,” she breathes out again. Her walls convulse around me, drawing me in.
Pushing her legs wide, I thrust deep into her over and over as she tries to hold herself back.
“I can’t. I’m going to…” She whimpers. Luke grabs both of her hands with one of his. He reaches down and plucks at her nipple. She cries out as she comes again.
“That’s two, kitten.” I keep thrusting hard and deep inside her. She moans as she can’t seem to come down. I fuck her harder, and she takes it beautifully. “You remember your word, right?”
“Mmhmm.”
“Do you want to use it?”
She shakes her head. Her dark eyes focus on me.
“Good.” My thrusts push her toward Luke.
Luke holds her hands down as he strokes his cock over his boxers.
“Now, Harper, one more.” I reach for her clit, sliding my finger over it in circles until she screams out. Her cunt gushes and tightens around me, trying to squeeze the life out of my cock.
Her body arches as I thrust in deep and find my release, coming deep inside her. Leaning back, I take in her flushed body before me. Her chest rises and falls as if she’s run a marathon. Her eyes are closed and her lips parted.
She’s gorgeous. I pull out and thrust my still hard cock back into her, sending her into another orgasm.
She cries out.
I pull out and turn her on her side, spanking her ass three times. Slowing down, I take my time, rubbing the pink skin as she huffs out her breath.
“Good kitty.” I can’t wait to do that again.
Lifting her head, she opens her eyes and meets mine. Luke still has her hands over her head, and she drops her head down onto the floor. “No words.”
“Think you could take more, kitten?” I slide my hand up her thigh, and she shivers beneath my touch.
“With a little practice.” She smiles and draws in a deep breath.
Nico
I figured this would be the part that would be too hard to watch. My friends all fucking my girl. The one girl I’ve longed for over the years. But damn, the way she takes them. The pleasure she receives.
Who am I to deny my girl that?
Eli strokes his hand down her side, and she sighs. His eyes lift to meet mine. She’s mine to take if I want. Luke helps her sit up, and she turns to me.
“Come here, sunshine.” I stand and give her my hands.
She grabs hold, and I hoist her up to stand with me.
“How about a shower?”
Her eyes widen, but she nods. I keep ahold of her hand and pull her toward the bathroom. Luke follows us. Not sure if he doesn’t want me to be alone with Harper or if he wants to join in. Either way, this is my turn.
I reach in and start the shower as Luke closes the door on the others.
“How are you doing, princess?” Luke threads his fingers through her hair, cradling the back of her head. Their bodies move in close to each other. He still wears boxers, but she’s completely naked.
“I’m good.” She reaches for his boxers and pushes them down. She kisses his cheek.
When he releases her, she moves over to me and grabs my boxers to help me out of them. Her dark eyes meet mine.
“Are you sore?” I ask as she rises to stand before me.
“A little, but it’s not going to stop me.” Her eyes are determined. She wants all of us. She said it before.
I make a noise in the back of my throat before ushering her into the shower. Caden’s shower is big enough for all six of us, so the three of us have plenty of space to move around.
She steps under the showerhead, and water flows over her curves. She pushes her hair back over her shoulder. Every inch of her is divine. From her full breasts to her narrow waist to her solid ass, she’s a teenage boy’s wet dream.
Luke stands beside me. She grabs the shampoo and eyes the two of us while she washes her hair.
“She wants all of us.” Luke’s voice is low, but she can hear him. “You’re the last.”
She steps under the spray again and rinses her hair. Her arms are up, elongating her form. Tempting me with that gorgeous body. The girl I knew had banged up knees and taught me how to catch fireflies.
This girl… I can still see some of my best friend in her, but she’s different. Not in a bad way. Just different. Luke steps in when I stay still. He grabs the conditioner and puts some in his hand before stepping behind her and massaging it into her hair.
She closes her eyes and moans softly. The sound is like a jolt of energy to my being. I close in on her front, grab her face in my hands, and kiss her, dragging her body against mine. Her arms circle my neck, and she presses every inch of that divine body against me.
All the other things fall away as I lay claim to her mouth. We have always been each other’s. It doesn’t matter that I’ve been with other women and she’s just been with my four friends.
She’s mine and I’m hers.
When I break off the kiss, I press my forehead against hers.
“Hi, sunshine.”
She smiles. “Hi, Nico.”
“Let’s get you clean. So we can dirty you up more.” I reach around her for a pouf and some soap. But then I think better of it and toss the pouf, putting the soap directly in my hands.
As I rub my hands together, her eyes darken. She leans back against Luke. He kisses her shoulder before biting down on her skin. She gasps. His chuckle fills the shower before he gently sucks the spot.
My hands glide over her breasts and down her stomach, making sure I cover every inch in bubbles. When I slide my fingers between her legs, she parts them for me. I lift my gaze to hers as I rub her clit.
“We have so much to teach you, sunshine.” I close in on her. Luke slides to the side when I back her up against the wall. “So many new things we can do, and when we get to your last first, it will open up even more possibilities.”
She strokes my cock while her wide eyes search mine. “But right now, are you going to fuck me?”
My mouth crashes down over hers as I lift her up against the wall. My cock slides deep into her pussy as her legs wrap around my hips.
“Like that, Harper?” I murmur against her lips. She tightens around my cock, making me want to just stay right here buried inside her wet, tight cunt. “Is this what you want?”
“Yes, Nico. Please fuck me.” She claims my lips as she wraps her arms around my neck.
If I had a choice for our first time, it would have been on a bed after a nice dinner out. But now I grab her hands and hold them up against the wall while I fuck into her. I pull back to meet her eyes.
“I like the way you feel inside me,” she whispers, like we’re sharing secrets.
“I like the way you tighten around me.” I thrust harder and deeper, until her head tips back and she lets out a guttural moan. Her cunt spasms around my cock as she topples over the edge.
I pick up the pace and join her, slipping over the edge into oblivion deep inside her for the first time.
Gathering her against me, I walk us under the shower stream and kiss her again.
Her hands dive into my hair and hold me there, like I’m going anywhere.
Not a chance in hell of that. I’m in this relationship or whatever the fuck we’re doing.
For me, this is it. After I pull out, I lower her to her feet.
She’s a little unsteady, but Luke comes up behind her to support her.
“I think it’s time for a nap, princess.” He takes the pouf and gently washes her as she clings to him. I help rinse her off and grab a towel to wrap her in when she steps out of the shower.
I kiss her nose as I dry her.
She blinks up at me. “What was that for?”
“For finally having my dream girl.” I draw her into my arms and hug her. My eyes meet Luke’s, and I see that touch of jealousy he always has with her. He’ll get over it eventually. Because jealousy can’t be a part of this equation.
Harper is more than willing to be shared at this point. And as long as she’s happy, I’ll be happy. And I’ll take on anyone who makes her unhappy, even if that means taking on one of my brothers.