Chapter Five
Jonah woke up with Finley’s arm still heavy across his back and Finley’s cock still inside him. Finley was hard again, but his knot seemed to have gone down, leaving Jonah with a phantom ache he kind of missed.
When he lifted his head, he saw that Finley was watching him. “Um. Hi.”
Finley grinned. “Hi. Feeling good?”
Jonah nodded. He realised there were two bottles of water on the nightstand next to the dildo and frowned at them.
Finley laughed. “Rafe brought us some supplies.”
“He was...”
“I covered you with the sheet,” Finley said. His fingers stroked down Jonah’s spine. “Though he seemed especially interested in looking.”
Jonah felt himself blush.
Finley sat him up, and Jonah winced when his cock slid free. They both drank and then Finley kissed him, rolling them again so Jonah was pressed back into the pillows.
“The toy,” Jonah moaned.
“Hmm, I should show you how to use it.” Finley reached out and grabbed it, then sat up so they could both take a look.
Looking at it now, Jonah was sure it was the same size and shape as Finley’s dick, so undoubtedly impressive. The bulge at the base made sense, too.
“If you flip this switch,” Finley said, indicating the switch on the base of the toy, “Then it’ll inflate or deflate the knot.” He flicked it one way, and it deflated, so all Jonah was holding was a regular – if large – dildo.
“What about the button?”
Finley pressed it and a low hum filled the air as the dildo began to vibrate. Jonah’s stomach clenched in anticipation, his cock jerking.
“Yeah, my cock doesn’t do that,” Finley said and chuckled. “But it’s not like this thing can fill you up, either.”
Jonah bit his lower lip. Finley leaned in and kissed him again, sucking on his lower lip until Jonah moaned into his mouth.
“Fuck, this isn’t...”
“Isn’t what?”
“Isn’t how I usually play with my toys.”
Finley huffed out a laugh. “I know.”
“You do?”
“Yeah. It took Ez a long time to find someone he thought might be... up for this. When he found you, he found your accounts, your videos. They were hot.”
“Oh God...”
“There’s a reason we were all so keen to meet you.” Finley kissed down Jonah’s throat. “You never show your face. We all wanted to see what you looked like when you cum.”
“Fucking hell.”
Finley took the dildo, gently, from Jonah’s slack grip. The thick head nudged against his hole, which was still slick with lube and cum. “Let me help you.”
”Please.”
Finley watched Jonah’s face as he eased the first inch of the dildo inside. They’d not turned the vibrations off, and it rumbled against Jonah’s perineum, making him pant in anticipation. “Finley...”
Finley grabbed the lube and slicked up the rest of the toy. “We might have to do another trial sometime,” he murmured, pushing the dildo in further. “Let you play on your own. We can all watch you from somewhere else, of course.”
Jonah let out a laugh that turned into a moan. “You’re all watching?”
Finley hummed his agreement. “Of course. We’ll all watch you play with yourself and then take turns to show you what you’re missing when you’ve just got toys.”
Jonah moaned when Finley tilted the toy again. It vibrated against his prostate. “You’re such an asshole.”
“I know.” He slid the toy out a little way, then thrust it in harder, letting out a pleased noise when Jonah whined. “That’s it, sweetheart. You’re so good at taking it.”
“Fuck,” Jonah muttered. He could barely think. Finley licked down his throat again, and the dildo was vibrating against his prostate, and he could feel how hard Finley was against his thigh and—
Finley pushed the dildo in all the way and held it there, turning the vibrations off. Jonah whined again, reaching for him. “Fuck, Finley, please...”
“Oh, you’ll get what you want,” Finley said. “But you need to feel the knot first.”
Jonah let out a ragged breath. He didn’t know if he could take it again. Finley brushed their lips together.
“Yes?”
Jonah nodded frantically, his eyes wet. “Yes. Fuck, yes.”
Finley flicked the switch and Jonah shook as he felt a similar pressure at his rim as he had before. It was less insistent than Finley’s knot had been but still had him whining and writhing, trying to get that thickness deeper.
Finley mouthed at Jonah’s shoulder, then travelled down to suck on one of his nipples.
“Enough!” Jonah gasped, and Finley flicked the switch so the knot stopped inflating. He bit Jonah’s nipple. Jonah whined again, fidgeting on it.
Fuck, but this was intense. Even without comparing, it was a lot, an experience Jonah had never had with another toy. The comparison... It wasn’t quite the same thing but fuck if it wasn’t as close as Jonah imagined a toy could get.
“Ready to cum, sweetheart?”
Jonah reached out, fingers drifting over Finley’s cock. He was hard again, wet at the head, and his eyes closed briefly when Jonah touched him.
“Don’t think I can fuck you again today,” Finley said quietly. “Seems like that would be a bit too much.”
Jonah frowned up at him. Finley’s eyes flicked over him, still silently possessive, and Jonah licked his lips. “Cum on me.”
Finley’s eyes widened in surprise.
“You’ve left marks all over me,” Jonah said, still breathing a little fast. “Mark me with your cum.”
A growl tore itself from Finley’s throat, and Jonah’s cock jerked in response. “Such a good boy,” Finley said. “I might not want the others to have a taste of you.”
Jonah smiled, baring his throat. “You don’t want me to be good for them, too?”
“Brat,” Finley said, but there was no heat in it. He moved to straddle Jonah’s hips, careful to avoid so much as brushing up against his cock. “I’d invite them all in to look at you after if I thought they’d be able to control themselves.”
Jonah moaned at the image. Finley made it sound like all those men... all those ridiculously gorgeous men... might lose it over him. “Finley,” he whined.
Finley grinned. “I’ve got you.”
He started stroking his cock even as he reached back and fumbled with the button on the base of the dildo. The vibrations started up immediately and when Finley pressed the button, holding it, it became more intense. He let go and ran a hand down Jonah’s torso, still stroking himself hard and fast.
“Oh, fuck,” Jonah whined. “Touch me, please, I don’t think it’s enough...”
“Not yet,” Finley replied. Jonah’s hips bucked up and Finley laughed breathlessly, his hips chasing his grip.
Jonah whined when Finley came, cum splattering over his chest and up to his chin.
Jonah’s tongue darted out, licking some up, and more cum dribbled from the end of Finley’s cock as he watched with bright eyes.
He sat back slightly and when Jonah’s hips bucked up again, his cock slid against Finley’s ass, notching for a second against his hole.
Finley pushed back against him, and Jonah cried out, cumming in spurts that slid down his cock and between the crease of Finley’s ass.
Finley growled and reached back, taking Jonah’s cock in a firm grip.
He stroked him and every muscle in Jonah’s body tensed as he came again, every drop of cum milked from his cock.
Jonah collapsed back onto the bed, chest heaving, and he hardly noticed as Finley turned off the toy and pulled it out, tossing it to the floor. Finley curled up behind him, pulling Jonah back against him. They were both sticky, covered in cum and sweat, but Jonah couldn’t bring himself to move.
Finley kissed the back of his neck. “So...?” he asked eventually.
“So, what?” Jonah yawned.
“How was it?”
“The toy?” He felt Finley nod. “Fucking... incredible. But I think I’d need to try it again to be sure. Without you there.”
Finley let out a huffed laugh. “Fair.” His hand drifted over Jonah’s hip. “Did you work out what I am yet?”
Because he wasn’t human, of course. It wasn’t that Jonah didn’t want to know. He just hadn’t thought about it while Finley was busy playing his body like a goddamn fiddle.
“No idea,” he said, turning in Finley’s arms. He swung one leg over Finley’s hip and Finley dragged him closer.
“Werewolf,” he said, and when Jonah’s mouth opened in surprise, Finley kissed him again.
“What about the others?” Jonah asked when they parted. Finley’s hands were on his ass again, fingers probing at his hole. Could Jonah get hard again? He wasn’t sure if Finley could.
“Oh, let them tell you themselves,” Finley said offhandedly. “You have anywhere else to be today?”
“No.”
“Good.” Finley’s grin turned devilish. “I’m sure Ez would love some video content for his new toys. I’m happy to be your cameraman.”
Jonah laughed and accepted another kiss.