69. Declan
She’d been incredibly tight when it’d just been my cock, but with Brogan fucking her ass, it was a fight to fully bury my length inside her.
As I tried, however, I could feel the sliding of his cock against my own, and it made me even harder.
I loved this man and this woman, and they both loved me back.
Once upon a time, I’d thought I lost all chances at ever having either one in my life again.
To have them both back was even better than I could’ve ever dreamed.
As I kissed and bit my way across her mouth, my lips were soon pressed against someone else’s.
Brogan angled his head, allowing me to thrust my tongue into his mouth, and his tangled with mine as we continued to fuck Enslee.
On occasion, we’d stop and focus on her mouth for a few seconds, but it always came back to this.
Brogan pulled away. “I’m not going to last much longer,” he warned me.
I watched as he attacked her ear with his teeth, causing her to move as we filled her. Incoherent and broken sounds escaped from those swollen lips of hers, and I could even see multiple drops of blood from our earlier possession of them.
“You’ve never looked hotter than when sandwiched between the two of us, Enslee.”
“She fits so perfectly as if she was made to be there,” Brogan added.
When she whimpered, I reached out and wrapped one hand around her throat. “Say you belong to us.”
“I-I-I…” she tried to get out, but each time she’d wince as we continued pounding her without pause.
“Say it, or else we’ll fuck you all night. We’ll prove to you that you have a place in this world, and that it’s right here on our cocks.”
She sobbed. “I b-belong to you both,” she managed to get out.
“Good girl,” Brogan crooned against her ear before latching onto and tugging on it.
“You’re so goddamned beautiful,” I started, but she shook her head, causing me to tighten my grasp on her neck.
“Do you want to know what I see?” I asked her.
This time, she nodded the best that she could due to my grip and I smirked.
“I see what a needy slut you are for our dicks. How you take us both inside you like a good girl. Mostly, I see how perfect you are for us. You complete us like the missing puzzle piece. If you weren’t ours before, you are now. ”
“Y-yours,” she moaned, then cried out as Brogan slammed into her and stilled.
I took that as my cue to drive into her over and over until the entire bed shook and not just her frame as I fucked her hard. Those pouty lips of hers were open in a silent scream, and I thrust three fingers between them.
And as my gaze moved from her to Brogan, pride swelled in my chest. My man was equally as hot, especially when he bit down on his bottom lip and didn’t even bother trying to hide the tension on his face as he tried his best not to come.
Our eyes met, and there was the promise of retribution, which made my own ass clench in anticipation. As if he knew, Brogan smirked, then started to move. I imagined he was inside of me right now, causing my head to fall back onto my shoulders.
“God, I’m about to come,” I warned them both.
“Please,” I heard just before Enslee tightened down on us both.
“Fuck,” I cursed before I climaxed alongside Enslee.
Brogan was there on the cliff, and while I loved to edge the hell out of my man, I wanted him to come too. Enslee was barely holding on to her consciousness at this point, so I needed him to get off inside her while he still could.
Grabbing her legs, I pulled her to me, then helped her wrap them around my waist as I stayed inside her. Once I did, Brogan moved behind her, gripped her throat, and held her head back. My mouth came down on his, and he started to fuck her hard.
The mewling sounds she made were music to our ears, and they mingled with the roar of my heartbeat currently racing in mine.
I felt every inch of Brogan while his cock slid alongside mine as he slammed into her repeatedly.
Enslee quickly came again, and Brogan groaned against my lips as he finally found his release.
After, Enslee went lax in our arms, and we pulled away, both grinning at the unconscious state we left her in.
Several minutes later after we had cleaned Enslee off while she dozed, Brogan and I were in the shower together. His breathing was as heavy and erratic as mine, and we stood like that for a bit before I pulled away and looked into his eyes.
“Are we still going to do what we’d planned?”
Sure, sex had been anticipated, but it hadn’t been the real reason we’d planned this entire night with Enslee.
Everything had played out perfectly with the three of us together in the same place at the same time.
The odds of that reoccurring again soon were slim to none, so I suspected I knew the answer even before Brogan spoke.
“We have to do it tonight,” he said to me. As he searched my eyes, concern suddenly filled his. “Unless you’ve changed your mind.”
“No, of course not. We’ve already discussed this ad nauseum, and we’ve decided together that this is what we want.”
“Then tonight’s the night. We will discuss everything with her.”
“Okay,” I said before pressing my lips to his. “I love you, baby.”
“And I love you too.” Brogan nipped on my bottom lip, then slapped my ass.
“For this next round, I want to feel more than your hands on my ass, Brogan. I want to feel you deep inside me.”
“One of my favorite places to be,” he responded as I stepped away from him.
Once we finished showering, Brogan went back into the bedroom to get Enslee.
I had filled the bathtub about halfway, then watched as he lowered her still drowsy body into the water.
We alternated between cleaning every inch of her as the other held her up until we lifted her from the water and dried her off.
Enslee woke more fully by that point, and although she went to protest when we ran a comb through her long hair, she finally relented and let us remove any tangles from it.
As I’d mentioned to Brogan a few minutes ago, I wanted him to fuck me.
As he did, I intended to fuck her ass where I’d tangle her long mane once more.
Half an hour later, we were lying together in the bed.
Brogan was turned on his side with Enslee’s ass nestled against him, while one of her arms and legs were draped over me as I lay on my back.
Relative silence stretched between us, and only the sounds of Brogan kissing her neck and shoulder snapped me out of the peace I was in.
Well, that and her squirming, which I suspected was because Brogan was toying with one of her breasts.
We hadn’t known her for a long period of time, but we’d both gotten to know her together and individually.
As such, it was easy enough to sense what sounds and movements were caused by what.
I’d never thought I’d want anyone more in my life than just Brogan, and I knew he felt the same.
Somehow, Enslee had come into our worlds and turned them upside down.
No, she actually turned them right side up. All was right when she was in our arms.
At the sound of her moan, I knew Brogan was starting on the second round. My dick hardened in anticipation, but we needed to settle everything else first. After, we could fuck each other’s brains out as we fucked hers out, and do so in celebration.
Running my hand up and down her back, she snuggled a bit more against me. A contented sigh left her lips, and I hoped she stayed as calm once I said what needed to be said.
“We’d brought you here for a reason tonight, Enslee,” I started.
“I know, and I’m pretty sure you've accomplished what you set out to do,” she responded softly and I heard Brogan chuckle.
“Fucking you was never the end goal tonight. While it was an added bonus, it wasn't our intention.”
Her entire body stiffened. “What do you mean? What did you plan to do? And why did you summon me here?”
Neither of us had thought she’d get defensive, and when our gazes met, our eyes were asking the same thing. “I don’t know,” I mouthed silently to him.
She attempted to sit up, but Brogan and I made sure to keep enough of a hold on her so she couldn’t move. “Calm down, Enslee,” I said.
“It’s nothing bad,” Brogan added.
“Then w-what is it?” she stammered.
“We want you to be ours,” I said to her.
“Yours?” she asked, and the confusion was evident in her voice. “You want me to be with both of you?”
“Yes,” Brogan responded.
“I was just with you both, so I don’t understand.”
“Not just sexually, but completely,” I elaborated.
She was silent for several seconds and I had no idea what she was thinking. Finally, she let out a sigh. “If this is because of what I’d told you both earlier, then—”
“We love you, Enslee. Honestly, we’d wanted you in our lives in ways that you weren’t even before tonight.”
“I don’t understand. You two love each other.”
“And we also love you,” Brogan said.
“We do,” I added.
“But you have a life together and I—"
“I won’t lie and say that my life with Brogan isn’t great and vice versa…”
“But our lives could be even better with you in it too.”
“What are you saying?”
“We’re saying that we want you to be ours in every way. We want more than sex and friendship. We want you… and every part of you, Enslee.”
“You can’t be serious right now,” she said, and I scowled.
Why are you fighting against something so natural?
“If this is about sex—”
“We don’t want you as just a fuck toy or someone we speak to on the telephone from time to time. We want you to stay with us… to be with us…”
“We want the life we’d first told you about,” Brogan added.
“That life wasn't real.”
“But we now want it to be real,” he replied.
I cleared my throat. “They say everything happens for a reason, and maybe having you there with us in that world full time was a sign. While it was never anything we’d ever thought we’d wanted, we’ve come to realize that it’s everything we’ve ever needed.”
“Our lives are so different. We all have responsibilities and obligations, and—”
“Brogan and I have always made our careers work with the other, so I know we can do the same with you,” I said.
“But how?”
“We don’t have all the answers, but it’s something we can figure out together. Do you not remember telling me over Christmas that when there’s a will, there’s a way?” Brogan asked her.
“It was different when it was just the two of you.”
“It’s no different. Compromise is compromise, no matter how many people are involved.”
“Surely, you both don’t really want me around all the time. If it’s about what I said earlier, or what we did earlier, we don’t need to jump into something so—”
“Again, fucking you was an added bonus and something that you’d needed at the time. Hell, it was something we all needed.”
“I’ve been on my own since I was twenty years old.”
“And you don’t have to be alone any longer,” I said before picking up her hand and trailing kisses over the top of it and her wrist.
“Despite my breakdown earlier, I can take care of myself.”
“We’ve never doubted that,” Brogan said as he kissed the top of her collarbone.
“W-when did you two decide on all this?”
“The night Declan got released from the hospital after the accident.”
“It was a new beginning for the two of us, and as happy as we were, we’d also realized that something was still missing.
That piece was you, Enslee. We understand it sounds far-fetched and all, but you’ve become so integral to our world, and we’ve missed you while you’ve been traveling the country. ”
“It’s taken months for us to be in the same place at the same time,” Brogan pointed out.
“But our careers, and…” Her voice trailed off.
“You can still do all the interviews and podcasts you want from New York City. You can travel to the different locations, but not have to do so in your van all the time. And Declan’s about to start filming the next season of his television show, while I’m in the city full time already.”
“This is crazy,” she said.
“What’s crazy is the time we’re wasting. We love you and want you to be part of our lives. And it’s not because we pity you or need a warm body to fill our beds. Enslee, we want you because we love you, and our lives are incomplete without you in them,” I said.
“There’s so much to think about… to consider…”
“Do you love us?” Brogan asked.
“I do. I just don’t want to put a cramp into your lives because I couldn’t bear it if either of you were to grow tired of me. If I were to lose the friendship we have, then—”
Brogan flipped her underneath him at the same moment that I sat up. She was now lying there between us as we stared down at her.
“No matter what you decide to do, just know you’ll never lose us,” I promised.
“And also know we’ll never give up trying to make you see what we already do. You belong to us, Enslee, and no more or no less than we belong to you. I’m not one to wax poetic about destiny, but if it actually exists, then you are ours.”
A few tears fell from her eyes as she smiled up at us. “I’m pretty sure I’m going to wake up to realize this isn’t real.”
“Then, we’ll need to prove to you that it is real.”
“And you’ll do it by—”
Her question was cut off as I moved on top of her, then fused my lips to hers.
Brogan got off the bed, then returned seconds later with some lube.
As he took his place behind me, I hiked up one of her legs, then buried my cock to the hilt inside of her as my other lover worked his fingers inside me.
Unlike before, I slowly moved in and out of her because we had all the time in the world with one another.
Being inside Enslee was coming home, and when Brogan gripped my hips and thrust fully into my ass, I groaned against her lips.
Taking Brogan deep inside and feeling myself stretch around him was also home to me.
I needed both of them in different ways, but never not together.
I raised my head and tilted it to the side as Brogan picked up where Enslee had just left off.
We kissed as he moved inside me and I did the same to her.
Only when her soft hands cupped my face did I lean down toward her.
As I did, I increased my speed as Brogan settled into a rhythm, and it wasn’t long before we’d all reached the same edge together.
“Come,” I said to both Enslee and Brogan, and the moment they did, I followed.
“I love you,” I heard Brogan rasp as he spilled his seed inside me, and shaky hands cupped my face.
“And I love you too,” Enslee said to me.
“And I love you… both… so fucking much.”
And wanting to prove it, I started to move inside of her again, causing her eyes to widen.
Brogan was still mostly hard inside me, and following my lead, he began to move again too.
Soon, we picked up where we’d left off, and I knew I was prepared to fight for this…
for us… and after we all came again, we lay there in each other’s arms.