Chapter 30 - Don’t Shut Me Out #2
“Fuck. Watching your cock disappear into Taryn’s beautiful pussy is the fucking hottest thing I’ve ever seen. I wish you could see it too.” Tucker closes the small distance between us and stops right in front of Taryn. “Can I touch you, baby?”
“Please, Tucker. Touch me.”
My best friend begins rubbing slow circles over her clit and I know our girl loves it from the way her inner muscles begin pulsing around me and from how much wetter she gets.
“Are you gonna come for us, baby?”
She doesn’t answer. Taryn tips her head back until she rests on my shoulder and succumbs to the pleasure that Tucker and I are delivering.
Her pussy tightens around me, pulsing as she falls apart.
I don’t know how I hold on to my control, but I do. “I wish you could feel what I just did.” I say to Tucker.
“I know. She’s so fucking perfect. Baby,” he then says to Taryn. “Can I come on your tits while Col fills your pussy?”
“That sounds so hot. I would love that.” She agrees.
If anyone had told me that watching my closest friend jerking his cock would be on my bingo card this year, I would have laughed.
And yet, I can feel Taryn tightening and coating me with more wetness, and my focus is mostly on how much she’s enjoying the show.
“Do you like how hot you make Tucker?” I begin fucking her from beneath her with slow, deep thrusts.
“Can you feel how hot you make me? I’m really close, but I think it would be fun if Tucker and I came together. ”
“Yes,” she moans.
Tucker surges even closer to us. “Baby, hold your tits together with both hands. Just like that. Can I fuck them a little?”
“Oh my God, Tucker, yes.”
I lean backward just enough to give Tucker the perfect angle.
He offers Taryn the palm of his hand. “Spit on my hand, baby.”
Tucker uses his wet palm to coat his hard shaft, and I watch as his cock slides between Taryn’s tits.
That view, combined with the tight embrace of her wet heat, is too much, and I know I’m seconds away from losing control.
“I’m gonna come.” Tucker announces one second later.
That’s my cue to sneak my hand around Taryn’s hips. I can’t see where her clit is, so I use my whole palm to rub her slick, smooth skin.
As the first ropes of Tucker’s cum begin hitting her collarbone and chin, I explode too.
And our girl follows us with a soft, sexy cry.
It takes us a few moments to come back down to earth.
“That was the hottest thing I’ve ever done.” Tucker says. “But when we decided to do this, we didn’t think about how messy it would be.”
He’s right. Taryn’s chest and the bottom of her face are streaked with his cum, and I can feel the mix of all of us starting to leak on my balls.
“Yeah,” I sigh. “There’s nothing here to clean ourselves up. And we both decided to wear dark shirts tonight.”
Tucker shrugs, taking his jeans off to slide his boxers down his legs. “Come here, baby.” He helps Taryn off me and uses his underwear to wipe her chest and face clean.
I do the same to clean between her legs.
“Thank you.” Taryn smiles once everyone’s clothes are back on. “Tucker, do you still have my panties?”
TARYN
The birthday boy nods, an ear-splitting grin on his face. “Yup. They’re in my pocket. But since Col and I are going commando, it’s only fair we all do. Besides, I was hoping you’d let me keep them to remember the best birthday I’ve ever had.”
I shake my head, but I’m laughing. “I guess the birthday boy should get anything he wants tonight.”
“Anything? Would I be pushing my luck if I asked you to sleep in my bed? If Colsen is ok with it too, of course.”
“I appreciate you considering me.” Colsen says. “I have no issues with it if Taryn wants to. Like she said, it’s your birthday. Even though it’s almost midnight, so technically you’re the birthday boy for ten more minutes.”
“It’s ok.” I giggle. “I’d love to spend the night.
But do I sound like the biggest party pooper in the world if I asked you if we could go home?
I promised Jodie and Talia that I would sneak one extra hour with them before regular practice to make sure we all have this week’s dances down to perfection. ”
“Yeah,” Colsen agrees. “We have practice at seven. Going home is the best idea.”
Tucker makes a wad out of our dirty underwear. “Let’s go out the same door we came in, so we can take these with us. There’s a trash can here, but leaving this stuff here feels rude.”
“Ok.” I make my way to the office door. “Let’s get out of here. Can someone text Talia to let her know that we’re going?”
“On it, baby.” Tucker winks at me.
Colsen wraps his arm around my shoulders, ushering me out of the room. “If you’re too tired to drive, I can. Mack texted me earlier that he was getting a cab back to camp with one of the girls on the team. Sorry, I can’t remember her name. It was a tall redhead.”
“It was… oh, hey Nash.”
Nash is leaning against the wall, right opposite the room we were just in.
“I wanted to see if you wanted to dance with me, but I couldn’t find you. One minute you were dancing with Tucker and then you disappeared.” His gaze is intent on my arm around her shoulders. “I guess Col found you before I did.”
In that precise moment, Tucker reaches us. “Hey baby, Tal said it’s ok, she wants to stay a little longer. Do you remember if the light was on or off when we got here?”
Something changes in Nash’s expression when he sees that Tucker is with us too. His eyes drift behind Tuck’s back, as if he expected to see more people coming out of the little office.
“I see you had your own little private party.” He bites out.
“Yeah, no. I came here with Tucker and then Colsen found us.”
His jaw pops as he keeps his eyes on me. “I see.”
“Hey dude,” Tucker’s tone is jovial. “Are you ok? I just wanted to have a minute alone with Taryn on my birthday. It wasn’t a private party or anything. Now we’re all a little tired, and we were gonna go home. You can ride with us if you’re tired too.”
“Yeah, I bet you’re all tired.” He points to a spot on my dress. “You have something white on there. Did you drop some cake on yourself?”
It’s obvious from his tone that he knows that isn’t cake.
I squirm under Nash’s probing gaze. “Ride home with us, Nash. We can talk in the car.”
He shakes his head. “No, thanks. I’m all talked out for tonight. I have a few things to think about; I’d rather walk to clear my head.”
“But it’s late, and it’s three miles to camp.” I object.
“Don’t worry about me. It looks like you’re in good company. You don’t need a fourth wheel. See you tomorrow morning at practice, guys. Try not to make too much noise when you come in.”
“Nash, wait.”
He turns on his heel, ignoring my plea.
“What the fuck is wrong with him?” Tucker asks no one in particular.
“I think he guessed that we were both in there with Taryn and he got jealous.” Colsen offers.
I’m so upset, I can barely speak without crying. “I was honest with him about how I feel right now. He said he didn’t know if he could ever share his girl long term but we talked and he kissed me. I thought we had time to figure this out.”
“You didn’t do anything wrong, baby.” Tucker comforts me. “Do you want me to catch up with him and talk some sense into him?”
Colsen grabs his shoulder to stop him. “No, Tuck. Let him cool down. He’s jealous and I can’t even blame him too much.”
My gaze finds his. I feel more upset with every passing second. “You don’t? Are you jealous too?”
He pulls me closer to his side and explains. “I’ll do my best to be as honest as possible, like Keene and Jamie said. I was jealous at first. I knew it was Tucker’s birthday, but I wanted to spend some time with you too. But then when I found you and you asked me to stay, I really liked it.”
Tucker pats him on the shoulder. “I liked it too, Col. Hottest night of my life so far.”
“I agree. And after what happened between the three of us, I think that maybe Jamie and Keene were right.”
“About what?” Tucker asks.
He explains to us what they told him about their relationship with Bex.
“Do you think something like they have could work for us too?” Tucker looks at me and Colsen.
“I don’t know. I think we could try if you’re on board. And if that’s something Taryn wants.”
Tucker runs a hand through his hair. “I don’t know.
Maybe before tonight, I would have thought that you were all crazy.
But I have to admit that every time I see you kiss Taryn, I think it’s hot, rather than feeling jealous.
And seeing you with her in that room was even hotter.
I want to be with my girl, but I don’t want to see you get hurt, Col.
So maybe we can try. What do you think?”
“I’m on your same page.” Colsen nods. “What about you, pretty girl?”
I feel my eyes fill with unshed tears. “Would you really want to keep dating me together?”
“Together was fun, so I wouldn’t say no to that.” Colsen chuckles. “But I’d love more time alone, too. We would figure it out as we go, but yeah. Maybe you don’t really have to choose between me and Tucker.”
“That would be awesome, but…” my voice breaks.
“But you care about Nash, too.” Tucker finishes for me.
“Look, baby, like Colsen said, we don’t have to decide everything tonight.
Let Nash cool down, and then we can all speak.
When we’re all more calm. Col is my best friend, so sharing you with him sounds possible.
But if he wanted to try to date you with us, I wouldn’t stand in his way. ”
Colsen agrees. “Yeah, me too. And if seeing you with us upsets him, we can work it out. As long as he understands that Tucker and I are starting to feel serious about you.”
“I’m starting to feel serious about you too.” I whisper. “You’re right, we have a lot to figure out, but it doesn’t have to be all tonight. I’m exhausted. Let’s go home.”
I walk back to my car holding hands with both my handsome, sexy men. With them, I feel safe. As I fall asleep with my head against the passenger seat’s window, I send a silent plea to the universe that Nash could be a part of us too.