Chapter 14 Matthew
CHAPTER FOURTEEN
Matthew
My cock pressed against Nick’s, and I really wasn’t sure how Evie was going to take both of us.
I ran my fingers through my short hair as Evie straddled Nick. His arms wrapped around her, pulling her flush against his body. We both had condoms on, and very selfishly, I wished we could do this without them. But, we’d save that for the future.
When Evie called me, I wasn’t really sure where we’d end up tonight. Everything was moving fast. I’d barely had a moment to process how perfect our date night had been. And yet, this was exactly what I wanted.
I dripped more lube on our cocks, pushing the gel into Evie too. As wet as she had been for us, I still wanted more lubrication to help her take us.
“Are you ready?” I asked.
“Yes,” they both said.
I closed my hand around both of our cocks, stroking them together.
Nick’s moan followed, and I glanced past Evie to him, his reaction like a bolt of electricity through me.
Kissing him had been unexpected, especially the way it’d made me feel.
He’d awakened something inside me, and I wasn’t sure I’d ever be able to turn away from it again.
I guided our cocks against her pussy. Evie whimpered as we pushed in at the same time. Slowly spreading her sweet cunt around the width of us. We took our time, and I kept adjusting us until we’d managed to fit the first couple inches inside her.
My gaze drifted back to the two of them. Nick’s hands caressed her back, his lips soft on hers. The way he sweet-talked her just made me harder. It felt like we were taking care of her together, and I loved the warmth that flickered in my chest at that.
“Oh god,” she panted.
My attention snapped back to her pussy and our cocks. I could feel the rungs of his piercing ladder against the underside of my cock, the friction good. “Should we stop?” I asked. “Too fast?”
“No. Please don’t stop. This feels so good. I’m adjusting.”
Evie whimpered and her head fell forward, resting against the crook of Nick’s neck. A smile fluttered on his lips, his warm eyes meeting mine. He gave a subtle nod, and we eased further inside her. Her nails dug into him as she panted through it, but she was taking us. Together.
“You’re doing so good for us, Evie.” I gave a thrust, pushing us deeper. “So fucking good for us.”
“She is,” Nick purred. He kissed the top of her head then groaned, his hips driving us even deeper. “Fuck.”
She kept making the most perfect sounds for us.
We took our sweet time, but eventually, our cocks were fully seated inside her.
Oh fuck. I could feel Nick’s cock, hard against mine, her pussy tight around us.
I’d never felt anything like this before, but I loved it.
My fingers dug into her hips. I yanked her back, ensuring that we were in as deep as we possibly could be.
Her wall squeezed around us, milking us together, tremors rolling through her muscles.
I loved seeing the pleasure on her face and knowing that we hadn't even really started fucking her yet.
We were just getting started.
“I’m ready,” she gasped.
Nick nodded, and together we pulled out of her, then thrust back in. Evie planted her hands in the blankets, lifting her torso just so slightly, her breasts pressing against Nick's face.
He growled, bringing one of her nipples to his mouth. He sucked eagerly, his cheeks flushed as we started to fuck her. I dragged my cock in and out with his, our bodies slapping together, the three of us making whines and moans as we chased the pleasure.
It was perfect.
I’d never done anything like this. Just the sight of them beneath me was enough to nearly make me come. I pushed away the feeling as best as I could. I wanted to savor every second of this. I wasn't ready to come. I wasn't ready to give in.
Not yet.
Soon, though, at this rate. There wasn’t going to be any resisting it. My head tipped back as I felt tingling at the base of my spine, my muscles tightening as I drove into her faster. Nick groaned as his cock slid against mine, his piercings giving more friction.
“Fuck,” he muttered. “I’m so close again.”
He let out another string of curses as Evie started to rock her hips, her slick heat enveloping us with every motion.
I slapped her right cheek and she gasped. Before I could apologize, she looked back over her shoulder, her teeth sinking into her bottom lip. “Again, please.”
I spanked her again, the sound of my palm against her skin cracking through the room. Her pussy clenched around us as I spanked her again and again, until her ass cheeks were bright red.
Fuck. Nick thrust up harder and faster, and between the two of them, I couldn’t hold out much longer.
“I’m so close,” she gasped.
Evie started to tremble, her gasps shortening as Nick drove her to the edge.
My cock throbbed inside her and I was fighting every urge to come.
Pleasure rocketed through me as I drove us in and out of her, until finally, her yell rang through the room.
She stopped moving, her muscles tightening, her pussy clenching around us as she came.
I pushed my cock in as deep as possible right as pleasure erupted through every muscle. I collapsed forward, panting as I pressed my forehead against her back.
Nick’s groan followed and he gave one more soft thrust. Perfect.
They were perfect.
Out of everything that had happened since moving to Whynot, tonight had to be the biggest surprise yet. Evie and Nick had crashed into my life, and I never wanted them to leave.
Carefully, I pulled out of her. Nick rolled her to the side and I flopped down onto the bed next to her, the three of us catching our breaths.
“Holy shit,” Evie whispered.
I nodded breathlessly. My eyes drifted shut, a smile on my face. I tangled my fingers with Evie’s, humming to myself.
“That was amazing,” Nick murmured.
“It was,” I agreed. I rolled over onto my side, sliding my arm over Evie’s stomach and resting my hand on his hip. He met my gaze over Evie’s shoulder and winked.
Fuck. I was so screwed. Both of them were everything I’d always wanted. The only missing piece was . . .
Possibly Austin. If he could get his head out of his ass.
“You’re beautiful,” I murmured to Evie. “Perfect.”
“Don’t worry, I already know you think I’m perfect too,” Nick chuckled.
I smiled as I kissed Evie’s collarbone, sinking against her. She was so soft and smelled sweet like a strawberry. “I guess you’re all right,” I teased him.
He feigned an offended huff. “I see how it is.”
The three of us laughed together, and took a couple minutes to clean up. When I came back with glasses of water, Evie groaned. “It’s my job to make the two of you drink water now,” I said.
“You’re so mean,” she pouted, but she drained half the glass for me.
Nick held my gaze as he drank every single drop. I narrowed my eyes on him. He was such a fucking brat. It made me want to explore the more dominant side of myself. There was something about his sassy attitude that made me want to spank him.
The corner of his mouth tugged. “Did you have water too? Can’t just be us.”
“Of course I did. I can’t be a good water Dom otherwise. Evie would never listen to me if I didn’t practice what I preach.”
“So true.”
She took one more sip and laid back down in the middle.
I studied the two of them, unable to stop.
They were so cute and cozy sprawled out in bed together.
Evie’s nipples were dark pink and taut, her stomach and thighs soft.
Nick’s muscles were etched like stone and he was covered in so many tattoos, all in the same style.
Evie scooted over to the right and patted the middle. “Come be the little spoon.”
My heart skipped a beat and my cheeks warmed with a blush. I crawled right into the center as Nick yanked the blankets up around our shoulders, his body pressing against mine as we all snuggled.
“I could fall asleep like this,” I whispered.
“Me too,” Evie murmured. “Stay. Both of you. I have to get up early, but . . . stay.”
Nick squeezed me gently. “Okay. I’ll stay.”
“I have to be up early too,” I said.
“We can have breakfast,” she said.
“Do you mean me eating you out?” Nick asked sleepily.
“No,” she snorted. “Well, maybe. Possibly.”
“Mmm, I’m in. Pancakes and pussy.”
Evie and I started laughing so hard, the bed frame squeaked. Every muscle relaxed as my eyes drifted shut.
For so long, I’d been chasing ghosts. Losing Amanda had broken me, but . . . Nick and Evie had already made me believe I could finally start putting the pieces back together again.