Chapter 22 Evie
CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO
Evie
Austin’s tongue flicked over my clit right as he eased two fingers inside me. A deep moan hummed in his throat, my cry ricocheting through the living room.
Just down the hall in my bathroom were my two boyfriends, and I could hear them moaning together occasionally. Matthew's voice carried past the sound of water running. Nick’s throaty moan followed, and my imagination was running wild wondering exactly what they were doing.
Austin pulled me straight back into the moment with him. Pleasure rippled through my body as his tongue circled my clit, his fingers moving in and out of me. I was soaked and with every driving pump of his fingers, could hear how wet I was.
He ate me out like a starved man.
For so long, I'd imagined what this would feel like. I'd imagined him getting on his knees, just like this, to worship me.
I never thought it would really happen, especially after years of pining over him.
It was way better than I ever dreamed.
Austin drew back, licking his lips. His beard was wet from my pussy, glistening beneath my living room lights. I reached for him, dragging his mouth to mine and kissing him openly. He groaned as he notched his hips between my thighs, grinding against me as his tongue dragged over mine.
“Fuck, Evie, thank you. Thank you for the chance,” he panted.
Well, fuck. That only made me more wet.
I gasped right as he plunged his fingers back inside me, pumping them in and out rapidly. I held his gaze, my nipples straining against my dress.
I was so fucking close, so close.
Austin Whynot was going to make me come.
“That's my girl,” he whispered. “Keep moaning for me. I want them to hear you come for me.”
Fuck. Not that this was a competition at all.
It wasn't. I didn't want to choose between the three of them.
However, the idea of him making me scream loud enough that Matthew and Nick would hear me—all because he wanted them to know he was making me come—turned me on.
My pussy gushed around him, my head falling back.
He tangled his fingers in my long, blonde hair, tugging hard as his rough fingers pushed me to the edge.
“Austin,” I gasped.
Lust burned in his gaze as he watched me. My hands slapped down on his shoulders, my fingertips digging into his muscles. He drew back into his lap, straddling me over his denim-clad thigh.
“Ride me,” he demanded.
The friction felt so good. My breath caught in my throat.
I'd never ridden a man's thigh like this before.
I rocked my hips, chasing that orgasm until finally, the wave hit me.
Pleasure washed through every muscle, and I cried out, not ashamed of how loud my voice was through the entire house.
I heard a door open, the sound of footsteps as my orgasm ebbed, my chest rising and falling with deep breaths.
When I opened my eyes, Nick and Matthew were standing there. Both of them were wet with towels wrapped around their waists. Nick’s skin was almost pink, and I was certain it wasn’t from the hot water.
Matthew sucked in a breath. “Fuck. The two of you look really good right now.”
“Join us,” Austin said.
My brows shot up in surprise. I sat back, meeting Austin’s gaze. “You want that?”
He nodded. “Nick is injured, so . . .”
“You don’t have to worry about me kissing you or anything,” Nick teased.
“Don’t worry. He’ll just have to watch,” Matthew said.
“You’re a fucking bastard,” Nick said, but he went to the chair and plopped down, letting his towel fall open. He leaned back, his eyes closing with a groan that had the three of us a little worried.
“You should maybe lie down in bed,” Austin said.
“What? Don’t tell me you’re worried about me, Whynot.”
Austin’s lip curled in a sneer at him, and the two of them glowered.
“For the record, Austin, I don’t like you. But if I hadn’t fallen off a roof, I’d make you suck my dick.”
“You could certainly try.”
Matthew and I looked at each other, both of us fighting a laugh because they must realize how silly they sounded, right? Maybe they just needed to sleep together . . .
“At some point, I’d like the full story on how the two of you started hating each other,” Matthew said.
He came up behind the couch and leaned over, planting a kiss on my lips.
“But only once the four of us aren’t completely turned on and needy.
Um . . . Nick and I have taken care of ourselves, so while I’m happy to join, I’m also happy to give the two of you space. ”
I didn’t miss Austin’s slight pout. “I want you to stay,” he said.
“Are you sure?” Matthew asked.
“Well, Nick could always leave.”
Nick snorted. “Nice try.”
Austin smiled, but continued. “I’m sure,” he said, his eyes on me. “Besides, I know Evie wants both of you. I know what I’m signing up for.”
Matthew planted his hands on either side of us on the back of the couch and looked down at Austin. He tipped his head back and smiled up at him.
“So are you open to dating now, Mr. Whynot?” Matthew asked.
Austin’s throat bobbed. He was blushing. It was cute, and made me giggle.
“I am,” he whispered.
I could see his vein pulsing in his neck, and I knew his heart was racing. He had such a crush on Matthew.
“I’m trying. Sorry in advance for how much you’ll have to put up with,” Austin said.
Matthew’s smile softened and he leaned down, his lips brushing over Austin’s tenderly. “I think you’ll find a lot of us like putting up with your bullshit, if you’ll let us try.”
I could feel his erection pressing against me, and it only grew harder as Matthew kissed him again. I glanced back over my shoulder at Nick, and he watched the three of us, his legs spread and hand on his cock, stroking slowly.
“Okay, okay.” Nick rolled his eyes. “Kissing is cute. Get to the good stuff, lovebirds.”
“He’s so demanding,” Matthew mumbled. “I would spank him if he wasn’t injured.”
“Didn’t stop you from fucking me.”
My brows shot up. “Didn’t you specifically say he was out of commission for the next week?”
“Yes,” Matthew huffed, giving Nick a dirty look. “Someone doesn’t listen very well but is convincing.”
I snorted and slid off Austin’s lap. Nick and Matthew were naked, so might as well join them, right?
I grabbed the hem of my dress and started to lift. Suddenly, all their eyes were on me. Hungry. Needy. I took my time, reveling in their undivided attention.
I was starting to unlock new things about myself. I’d always felt confident in my body and looks, but there was something so deeply satisfying about being appreciated by three people at the same time. I liked how they were each looking at me right now.
My skin was still flushed from my last orgasm, and I knew my pussy was wet. I pulled my dress overhead and dropped it to the floor. Matthew let out a low groan. “Have you been wearing that all day?”
I had. It’d been a wild last-minute decision this morning that I figured I’d regret, but now I certainly didn’t. Finally, I was getting to show off the strappy black set of lingerie I’d teased Matthew with days ago.
It was perfect. I felt like a goddess, especially with the way the three of them looked like they wanted to devour me.
“Doctor,” Nick rasped. “I can’t wait a full week for sex. This is already torture.”
“Sorry,” Matthew groaned. “So sorry. You’re just gonna have to watch me and Austin.”
“I’m going to die,” Nick complained.
Austin’s eyes were wider than saucers, the bulge in his pants apparent. I tilted my head to the side, holding his gaze.
“Are you sure?” I whispered.
I didn’t want him to do something that might make him uncomfortable. And I certainly didn’t want our first time together to be something he’d regret.
Austin slid to the floor on his knees, and inched closer to me, until he was kneeling at my feet. I slid my hand along his jaw, my body tingling as he looked up at me with eyes I’d never seen before.
Unguarded. Raw. Completely Austin without all the walls up.
“I promise you I’m sure,” he said. “Are you okay with this? The three of us? Are you okay with me joining?”
“Yes,” I said.
Austin glanced over at Matthew too, questioning. He nodded, “I am too.”
Then his gaze slid to Nick. Their expressions hardened, but Nick gave one nod.
“I’m good at sharing,” he said pointedly. “Can you be?”
“I can,” he said tightly. “I still don’t like you.”
“Yeah, yeah. Fuck off, Austin, and show me what you’re made of.”