Chapter 36
CHAPTER THIRTY-SIX
Matthew
I loved being the one in charge.
Austin and Nick naturally defaulted to me, and there wasn't much else that pleased me more. Maybe aside from seeing Evie already slick and naked for us. A blush crept across her chest, her eyes wide as they undid the straps around her ankles together.
She was so fucking gorgeous, I couldn’t take my eyes off her. My body thrummed with need as my gaze raked over her, appreciating the swell of her breasts and the way her nipples were already taut for us, begging to be sucked again.
I unbuckled my belt and pulled it off slowly, taking my time as I stripped off my clothing. My cock was painfully hard. I wanted to be lying back on that bench with her bouncing up and down on my cock right now.
Soon. It would happen soon.
Pre-cum dripped from my cock as it came free. I sat down in the middle of the sex bench, stretching back along the curve of it. It was just the right angle, dipping in a way that would let her ride me with ease. I planted my feet on the floor, lounging as I watched them.
Nick grabbed a fistful of her hair, pulling her head back as he devoured her mouth, Austin's hands gliding up and down her gorgeous curves.
It was funny how those two didn't even blink when it came to pleasing her together, or hell, even pleasing me.
All rivalries fell to the side when it came to sex.
“I don't want you to wear a condom,” Evie gasped, her eyes landing on me. “Is that okay?”
I nodded, stroking my cock as I drank her in. Her hair unraveled completely, her long golden waves falling over her shoulders. “Yes. More than okay with me.”
“It’s more than okay with all of us,” Austin said. “I’ve been wanting to do that forever.”
“Good,” I said.
“I want you to come inside me,” she moaned. I loved the way her bottom lip quivered, her brows drawing together as they kept teasing her. She was going to be such a good girl for us. “All three of you. Together.”
Nick groaned, grazing her cheeks with his knuckles. He gave her one more kiss then drew away, his cock straining against his jeans. I wanted him out of those just as badly as his cock did.
“That sounds like a plan,” Nick choked out, his voice husky.
I’d gotten off so many times thinking about filling her with my cum and watching it drip out of her. Fuck, watching it drip out of Austin or Nick too.
Austin took her hand, leading her to me.
He yanked her close, kissing her until she was breathless and pink all over again, then helped her straddle my hips.
Her breasts pressed against my face and I grunted, taking a nipple into my mouth and sucking.
I couldn’t get enough of her. She hovered over the head of my cock, and I reached down, guiding myself against her wetness.
“Oh, I love this,” she rasped.
“Do you mean the sex bench or me?” I chuckled.
“Both.”
My chest warmed. The head of my cock pressed against her pussy, slowly stretching her around the girth of me.
She was already wet, her slickness helping her give way as she sank down on my raging cock.
I kept sucking her nipples, caressing her until she was squirming, whimpering as she took it inch by inch.
“Hold on, right there,” Nick said. “Before you take all of him. I need to get you ready for me.”
She leaned forward, and I was in heaven.
My face was buried between her tits, my cock throbbing inside her.
Nick would try to work himself inside her other hole, and Austin would use her mouth.
God, I wanted to see him come inside her mouth.
I wanted to watch him unleash all over her pretty pink tongue.
Nick straddled the end of the sex bench, lining himself up with her. I heard the cap of lube open and let out an approving sound as he applied it to her. Her pussy kept flexing, milking me as she waited patiently. She sighed and moaned, her eyes shut, expression blissful.
I felt so lucky to be here with them. Lucky to have them in my life. How long had I wished to fall in love again? Years.
Austin moved up closer to us, and sometime in the last couple minutes he'd completely undressed. His hand closed around his cock, pumping himself as he watched Nick and I take her together.
“Fuck, the three of you look so good.” He let out a low moan, his hand moving faster.
I reached for him, slowing his strokes. “Give him your mouth, baby,” I said to Evie.
She adjusted herself, more of my cock pushing inside her as she leaned over, her eyes locking with Austin as she parted her lips. He huffed as she took his cock in his mouth.
‘That’s right,” I whispered. “All the way, baby. You’re sucking him so well, aren’t you? Did you miss having one of us in your mouth?”
She nodded, her eyes glistening as she took him deeper. She had this hungry look there, as if she was starving for him.
Nick’s hands settled on her hips, his gaze meeting mine over the curve of her shoulder.
“Ready?” he asked. “I’ll go slow.”
Evie nodded with a breathy yes while still sucking Austin. He gathered her hair up in his hands, holding it as she took him deeper.
“Ready,” I grunted, nodding at Nick.
Nick edged forward, slowly spreading her hole with his cock. My eyes widened when I felt the pressure against my own cock too, her body tightening around us.
Her mouth released Austin with a gasp. “Fuck.”
“Too much?” I asked.
“No,” she groaned. “It is too much, but in a perfect way. I’ve never been so full before.”
“I’ll keep taking it slow. Tell me if I need to stop.”
“She will,” I said, watching her nod in agreement.
Nick eased further inside her, taking his time and making sure she was adjusting to us.
By the time his pelvis bumped against her, my cock was pulsing with the eager need to come.
I was so close already, just from waiting patiently and feeling his cock slide inside her, hearing the beautiful sounds she and Austin made together as he fucked her beautiful mouth.
He pulled free, giving her a few moments to catch her breath. She leaned back, just enough so that I could arch up and kiss her. Her tongue slid against mine and I groaned, rocking my hips. I caught her gasp in my mouth and smiled, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear.
“I’m ready,” she whined. “Fuck me. Please.”
Nick blew out a breath and grinned, his piercings catching the light as he tilted his head. “Whatever you want, baby.”
She gasped as he thrust fully into her, and it made me groan too.
She planted her hands on the bench to either side of my head and cried out as we started to move in tandem, taking her together.
Austin knelt on the edge, offering her his cock.
She took it, swallowing him down as he started to take her mouth to the same rhythm.
She fit perfectly between the three of us. She was perfect. Everything about her; I loved feeling the weight of her body against mine, the softness of her thighs and breasts. I sucked one of her nipples, driving my hips up harder, listening for all the horny sounds she made.
There wasn’t anywhere else I would rather be.
I wanted this forever, I realized. I wanted this every day. Nick had talked about the house and how big it was and he’d put the idea in my head—what if we all lived together? What if we built a life together?
Yes, I’d be further from the hospital, but it would be worth it.
I wanted it. I really wanted it with them.
All my thoughts fell away as my focus returned to Evie. Her lips fit so perfectly around Austin’s cock. Her cheeks were red and eyes glassy. I couldn’t stop looking at her.
Her pussy kept milking me, squeezing me tight with every movement.
“Fuck,” Nick groaned. “This feels amazing. I can feel you taking both of us, squeezing our cocks together.”
“She’s doing so good,” I purred. “Our beautiful girl. Fuck.”
I arched up, shoving my cock deeper inside her as Nick did the same. She whimpered around Austin, sucking him faster, working him to the same rhythm. The bench squeaked under us as Nick started to pound into her, his gaze locking with mine.
Fuck. I couldn’t look away from him. I was already on edge, enjoying the sensation of feeling her flesh against mine, no barrier keeping her from me.
Nick gave me a cheeky smile, sweat beading on his forehead. He leaned over her in the same moment I arched up, kissing him over her shoulder. He grunted, his tongue exploring my mouth, followed by a whimper. I reached up, sliding my hand behind his neck, holding him there as I devoured him.
“I’m so fucking close,” Evie suddenly gasped. “Oh god.”
I released him so he could fuck her harder, and he did.
The sound of our bodies slapping together filled the room and Evie let out a cry, her head tipping back.
Austin grunted, stroking his cock as she shook, her pussy squeezing me so tight I almost released.
I felt her orgasm all the way in my bones, in awe as she came for us.
She relaxed against my chest, panting hard. Nick and I slowed our movements, but didn’t stop thrusting, fucking her through every tremor of pleasure. Her fingers pressed into my chest, her hips rocking ever so slightly.
“That’s our girl,” I whispered in her ear.
She moaned, pressing her face against my neck. Nick smiled, thrusting a little harder until she crooned. “Oh god.”
Nick gripped her hips. I could feel the ribbed bumps of his piercings through her with every thrust, I realized. I shivered, my cock straining.
Evie pushed her torso up and reached for Austin, taking over his stroking again and guiding him to her lips. I rubbed her sides as I started to thrust up, fucking her with Nick.
I was so close. So, so close.
Nick slapped her ass and she moaned, her pussy tightening around me in response.
“Spank her again,” I demanded.
Nick complied, spanking each cheek until she cried out around Austin’s cock, bucking her hips.
I wrapped my arms around her and brought my hips up. With every harsh thrust, she moaned for us.