Chapter 40
CHAPTER FORTY
Evie
This week had been something else. We’d all been on a rollercoaster between the bullshit with Phil, Austin disappearing for a couple days, and the everyday grind of running my own business.
Avery was still throwing up a lot, so I was starting to worry about her. Although, her mom had promised she’d been exactly like that with her first pregnancy too. I wasn’t sure I’d ever seen Levi or Mateo so stressed.
They were gonna be the cutest dads.
Dallas, June, and Madi were already stockpiling diapers and supplies and they were going to be the best aunts and uncles. Just like me.
I was so excited. I’d already been in the aunt role to June’s niece, and loved Laura so much. Plus, she was doing great and June’s brother was finally in a much better spot. So, getting to be an aunt again, but this time to Avery’s kid? It was going to be amazing.
With everything going on, I’d felt like I’d been pulled in a thousand different directions.
It’d been so busy, I barely had time to think.
But tonight held the promise of dinner and sex, and I could not complain at all.
After another grueling day at the bakery, I was ready for some TLC in the form of getting smashed by my three hot boyfriends.
I went through Nick’s front door and called out. “Honeys, I’m home.”
I frowned when there wasn’t an immediate answer. I’d seen everyone’s cars in the driveway, so . . . where the hell were they?
Lucky let out a soft meow and greeted me, weaving between my legs as I slowly took off my boots.
I heard a smack from across the house and my eyes went wide.
Had they gotten started without me?
God, I hoped so.
I’d gotten so much action over the last couple months, there was a very real part of me that would be more than happy to sit back and just watch.
Voyeurism had been on our checklist. For all of us.
Finally, we’d made an official yes and no list for each other, and I explicitly remembered seeing that on the list. I’d never thought about it in this context, but as I locked the front door and crept down the hall, I got a thrill out of being sneaky.
It was a solid, complete yes, I reminded myself. So I wasn't doing anything bad by sneaking down the hall and watching them . . . right?
I kept my footsteps light. My heart thundered in my chest, my eyes widening as I came to the door of the BDSM room. It was cracked open just enough for me to see exactly what was going on.
My mouth dropped.
Holy shit.
Austin and Nick were both on their knees. They were blindfolded, and both had their heads tilted up, groaning together. They’re so hot. I could count every single one of Nick’s abs from here, along with all his tattoos. Austin’s arms rippled with strength as he put them behind his back.
Matthew walked around them, his voice too low for me to hear what he was saying. But I knew they were submitting to him, the same way I loved submitting to him as well.
Oh my god, Austin had the spreader bars on. Matthew went behind him, giving him a shove. He landed on all fours, his cock hard between his thighs. He whimpered, his breath catching as he pushed his ass back.
This was one of the hottest things I’d ever seen. I blushed, trying to keep myself quiet, even though it was hard to. I was certain my heart was beating so loud they could hear it.
Nick liked to tease me about all my little fantasies. And the truth was, I did have a lot of them. I wasn't ashamed of that fact.
And I certainly wasn't ashamed as I melted to the floor, my hands hiking up the skirt of my dress, my fingers sliding against my pussy, finding myself completely drenched for them already.
Did they do this on purpose? They knew I was almost home. They knew I was almost here.
This was way better than any dinner plans we could have had.
I’m so wet. Fuck.
Matthew pulled off Nick's blindfold and pointed at Austin. My eyes widened even more as Nick crawled to him, and the two of them kissed.
Oh my fucking god!
Austin and Nick were kissing. They were kissing! After all this time, they were finally kissing.
And I was watching them kiss.
Matthew looked up at the door and winked. Uh-oh. I’d been caught. But instead of calling me out, he turned his attention back to the two of them.
Without a doubt, he’d planned this. But I also knew he wouldn't force the two of them to kiss, so did that mean . . .
A grin slowly crept across my lips.
Nick had sent a cryptic text the other day after visiting Austin, and Austin had been suddenly very cheery after being depressed for a couple days. I’d assumed Nick had worked his charming cocky magic, but maybe there’d been more cock in that than I’d realized.
Whatever had happened, it made me happy.
Matthew and I had been waiting for this.
This also meant Matthew had won our little bet, so I’d be taking him out to dinner.
Happily, too. I’ve been waiting for the two of them to finally give in to the tension that had been boiling between them since Nick had come back to Whynot.
It’d been so completely impossible to miss unless you were the two of them.
So finally seeing them kiss? It was a dream come true.
I stifled a gasp as I circled my clit, never taking my eyes off them. Nick groaned as he kissed Austin deeper, his hand cupping the back of his head.
Matthew knelt behind Austin, and my mouth dropped yet again.
Matthew started working in his hole with his tongue, rimming him.
Teasing him. A bottle of lube was there waiting to be used, but Matthew was always patient when it came to domination, and he took his time—pushing Austin until he was a whimpering, breathless mess.
That’s my man.
The man I’d been in love with since forever.
And the two men I’d fallen head over heels for, too.
I was lucky. So, so lucky.
“I want him to suck my cock,” Nick gasped. “Please. Can he?”
“Yes,” Matthew decided. Then, he leaned forward, whispering something in Austin’s ear.
“Fuck,” Austin groaned, his head turning. He almost looked like he was trying to find me, but the door kept him from seeing me.
I felt so naughty, kneeling on the floor, touching myself while watching them fuck each other. I slid my fingers inside myself, keeping my moan quiet as I pumped them in and out slowly. I couldn't take my eyes off Matthew, Nick, and Austin.
Matthew gave Austin's ass a slap, lining his cock up with him. In the same moment, Nick rose up onto his knees and offered him the head of his own cock.
Austin immediately took it, sucking him right as Matthew thrusted forward. The three of them cried out together, their voices echoing through the room. I covered my mouth, trying to hide my gasp as I circled my clit faster.
I was going to come just from watching them.
My heart thundered in my chest as Matthew started to fuck him relentlessly, driving in and out of him at a pace that had me wanting to try and keep up.
I rubbed myself faster, waves of pleasure rushing through my body.
I felt electric. I was tingling all over, every single nerve alive with the rush of need.
Voyeurism, without a doubt, was one of my kinks. I’d never known that until now, given I’d never been able to explore it like this. I was going to be thinking about this moment forever.
Matthew started to fuck Austin even harder.
He and Nick found the perfect rhythm that had him bouncing back and forth between their cocks.
Austin took both with ease, his voice muffled music to my ears.
I loved every sound he made for them, and wondered if he knew I was here watching.
Did he know I was just on the other side of the door?
Did he know that Matthew had set this up?
“That’s right,” Matthew growled. “You’re taking us so well, aren’t you?”
Nick pulled out of his mouth and stooped down to kiss Austin again, stroking himself as he did so. Then, he shocked the hell out of me by rolling over onto his back and sliding under Austin, moving his head to be right under Austin’s cock, and positioning his right there for Austin’s mouth.
Fuck. I stopped touching myself for a moment, my eyes wide. I’d never even thought of this position before. Shock rumbled through me, and it was enough to put me right on the edge.
I started circling my clit even faster as they sucked each other, all as Matthew pounded into him from behind.
“I’m going to come,” Matthew gasped. “Soon. But don’t come. Either of you. I’ve got a plan for you.”
“Yes, Sir,” Austin panted before sucking Nick again.
“Fuck,” Nick moaned. “I’ll do my best.”
Matthew chuckled, his hips thrusting harder. He grabbed onto Austin and turned his head, looking up at me. I couldn’t hide my gasp this time as Matthew looked right at me, fucking our boyfriend until finally—his eyes squeezed shut and he moaned, coming inside him.
My orgasm tore through me, and I cried out, not even caring if they heard me now. My head tipped back as I rode through every current of pleasure, my hips rocking as it trembled through me.
I was left panting and on cloud nine, sinking back on my heels with a soft sigh.
When my eyes opened, the door was wide open, and Nick was right there with a cocky grin.
“Hi, baby,” he said. “You’re a naughty, naughty girl, aren’t you?”
“Yes,” I rasped.
He held out his hand and pulled me to my feet. I stumbled against his chest, and he wrapped his arms around me, kissing my forehead gently.
“Bring her over here,” Matthew demanded.
He and Austin were putting pillows and blankets down on the rug in the center of the room. I squeaked as I was guided there, and found myself sprawled out on the floor, my knees spread, and Austin’s hips right between them.
“Kiss her,” Matthew said.
The corner of Austin’s mouth tugged and he leaned down. I met his kiss eagerly, whining as his tongue slid against mine. I wrapped my arms around his neck, holding onto him as I heard a shuffle of movement.