Chapter 40 #2
“My turn to be a little voyeur,” Matthew chuckled. “Nick, you know what to do.”
“I sure do,” he said, his voice husky.
Austin stopped kissing me, a sharp gasp leaving him. His eyes squeezed shut as I looked past his shoulder. Nick settled right behind him, winking at me.
Oh.
“You know,” Nick said. “Between the four of us, the options are endless.”
“It’s true,” Matthew laughed. “Thousands of combinations between the four of us.”
“Thousands,” I teased. I gasped as Nick shoved Austin harder against me, the head of his cock pressing against my pussy.
“Well, with all of our imaginations,” Matthew said. “I’m certain we can think of alllll the positions.”
“Especially Evie’s,” Nick rasped. “Naughty mind.”
“Shut up,” I groaned.
They all laughed, and Austin’s voice grew strained as he moaned.
“I need you inside me,” I panted in his ear. “Now.”
Nick slapped his ass. “I’m about to be inside him too. Now.”
Austin sank his cock into me right as Nick did the same to him, and we all cried out together. My arms wrapped around Austin as he started to thrust into me, and I felt Nick fucking him too.
“Fuck,” Austin growled. “This feels so good. Fuck.”
All I could do was nod, moaning with every single thrust of his cock.
He spread me with every thrust, hitting the perfect spot.
The sound of Nick taking him slapped through the room, and seeing their movements, feeling them around me—it was enough to put me right back where I’d been only moments ago.
Pleasure pumped through every part of me, my toes curling as I cried out their names.
“I’m so close,” Nick said. “Matthew? Please.”
“Please,” Austin chanted. “I’m right there.”
“Come,” Matthew demanded harshly.
He didn’t need to tell any of us twice. I arched up as my orgasm rippled through me, heat rushing through my veins, my muscles shaking as I came hard around Austin’s cock. He and Nick both grunted in pleasure, and I felt hot cum filling me with every single drop.
I melted into the floor in a daze. Matthew leaned over, kissing me gently on the lips. I smiled against his mouth. I felt like I was floating. This is everything to me.
“Good girl,” he murmured between kisses. “I love seeing you like this.”
I love you. It wasn’t the first time I’d thought it. I almost said it too, but kept it inside, smiling as the feeling spread through me.
“That was amazing,” Nick sighed happily.
“We’re about to make a mess everywhere,” Austin chuckled.
“Stay there,” Matthew said, standing up quickly. “I’ll grab towels and wipes.”
He disappeared for a couple minutes, then returned with everything. The four of us took some time cleaning up, then I was deposited onto the giant bed between Matthew and Austin, with Nick on the other side of Austin.
“Wait,” I said, raising my head. “Someone care to explain when this happened?”
Matthew chuckled. “You want to know something about those two idiots?”
“Hey,” Nick called. “You like us.”
“I more than like you.” Matthew slid his arm around me, meeting my gaze.
“I walked through Nick’s front door, and they were on the couch, shirtless and making out.
And you should have seen how fucking smug they were about it, Evie.
They were gonna surprise both of us, but .
. . Well, then we thought of another surprise. ”
“Oh god. That was the best surprise ever,” I said, my head plopping back against the pillow. “Although you guys should have your own date nights too. I can always hang out with my friends and drag them away from their partners for an evening.”
“We’ll do that,” Austin chuckled.
“We’ve got all the time in the world,” Nick sighed happily.
“I’m glad . . . I’m glad you two are together,” I said.
“Me too,” Austin agreed. “Just took some work. Also . . . I scheduled my first therapy appointment.”
“He did,” Nick said. “He made appointments, and he took things off his books. I’m teaching him the art of delegation.”
Austin elbowed him, but Nick only grinned, tightening his arms around him. They were so so cute.
It was always so easy with them. We settled into chatting and I lost track of time. I laughed so hard in some moments that my sides hurt. I kissed each of them so much, my lips were gonna chap.
And it was everything I wanted and more.
“I think I’m gonna nap,” Nick finally sighed, turning over onto his side. “I’m exhausted.”
“Agreed,” Matthew said with a yawn. “At least for a little while.”
Austin hummed in agreement, his arm sliding over my stomach. “The bed is certainly big enough. You guys sleep.”
“Mm-hmm,” Nick mumbled. “Night night.”
Austin chuckled. “Night night.”
Was this going to be our lives forever? I wanted it to be. I wanted this. More than anything else.
I stared at the ceiling, listening to our breaths and the way they fell in sync.
Matthew soon started snoring, and Nick’s breaths deepened as he fell asleep too.
I’d never felt more at home than I did right now, in this bed, in their arms, wanted and loved.
This was where I belonged, where we all belonged.
But did they want this too? Did they want this as much as I did?
Hope was a butterfly in my chest, its wings beating against my ribs. I love them. I had a sneaking suspicion they loved me back. But did they love each other? Even with Nick and Austin now wanting each other . . .
“You’re thinking so hard right now,” Austin whispered against my ear. “What’s wrong?”
I’m scared this will all fall apart. I’m scared I have everything I’ve ever dreamed of and it’ll all be taken away.
“Nothing is wrong,” I murmured. “In fact, everything is perfect.”
And that scared me.
Austin’s hand rubbed my hip gently, his lips pressing against the top of my head. “Go to sleep, baby. You’ve got us.”
I squeezed my eyes shut, and nodded, holding onto that feeling of hope with all my might.
Maybe, just maybe, this would be my forever.